Aloha everyone. As per my custom, below is an unedited  paper written by Tracy Dudick (a rockstar evening student at McGeorge) during my last Craft Beer Law class. This paper examines the sometimes complex relationship between craft beer and legal cannabis.  While there are some similar studies out there, Ms. Dudick provides some great insights and ideas.  See below

Craft Beer and Cannabis Can Coexist

There has been a shift in consumer choice and what is considered culturally acceptable when it comes to legal intoxication. Where nights that used to be filled with a case of domestic beer and joints of a friend’s uncle’s marijuana, now involve a twelve pack of local craft beer and a stop by the neighborhood dispensary. Even more recently with the coronavirus pandemic, the cannabis industry has reached a new level of legitimacy – as cannabis, as a whole, was deemed an “essential” part of life nationwide.

As the cannabis industry continues on the road to legalization, it has been predicted legal marijuana usage could adversely impact the demand for alcohol. However, data suggests legalization in the short term has not affected craft beer sales. In fact, these fears are predominately felt by Big Beer and further pushed through media outlets to create hesitation among the alcohol industry to support marijuana legalization.[1] Despite this rising fear, it seems local craft breweries and some of the world’s largest macro-breweries are leaning into the cannabis industry. At this point, there is no reason to think cannabis and craft beer cannot peacefully coexist, or even support one another.

  1. Craft Beer and Cannabis Can Coexist.

As a preliminary note, marijuana and hops are cousins in the plant world. Cannabis and craft beer are both products of counterculture – where craft brewers have fought for their place in the beer industry, cannabis continues on a slow and uncertain road to legalization. Unlike craft beer, the marijuana industry’s approach to start-up cultivation is considerably more difficult because of higher entrance barriers and stricter regulations.[2] Specifically, the federal government remains marijuana’s most prominent barrier to reaching its full potential. While craft beer is successful at navigating regulatory hurdles, the industry still faces blockades from all levels of government that hinder its true growth.

When the craft brewing industry emerged, the focus departed from America’s typical macro lager and shifted to traditional styles from Europe.[3] This departure led to craft brewers competing to make stronger beers, which subsequently led to greater consumer choice. The craft beer industry’s ability for innovation allows them to offer new products that give consumers choices they previously did not know existed, thus uncovering preferences they did not even know they had. Alike, cannabis innovation can come from anywhere – a grower in their garage or a corporate lab.

According to BDS Analytics, a cannabis market research company, 54% of cannabis users drink beer; however, about half of the cannabis consumers who drank alcohol do not view the two products appropriate for the same occasion.[4] In fact, over a sixth month study, BDS found only 13% of cannabis consumers said they paired marijuana with craft beer. Nevertheless, 68% of cannabis users said their consumption of craft beer stayed the same.[5] Therefore, the evidence suggests the craft beer drinker is not substituting craft beer for a cannabis product – but rather consumes different products at different times.

However, this is not necessarily true in Canada, where marijuana has been fully legal nationwide since October 2018.[6] According to analysts at Wall Street’s Cowen and Co., they believe Canadians are smoking more marijuana than drinking beer because beer sales dropped off by nearly 6.8% in March 2019, which at the time, was the most significant hit in over two years.[7] Moreover, analysts directly connect Canada’s fading interest in beer to the country’s move to legalize marijuana.[8] However, it begs the question if this data considers the considerable change in the beer market in Canada – where mass-marketed, light-bodied lager are on the decline and craft beer is on a rise. Can one really blame it on the weed?

Maybe not. Bob Pease, president and CEO of the Brewers Association, believes the brewing sector is only getting bigger in states that have legalized marijuana – specifically in Colorado, California and Washington. For example, Colorado was one of the first states to legalize marijuana for recreational use and beer sales have not shown any signs of being in jeopardy.[9] In fact, Colorado broke a beer sales state record last year – consuming 1.6 million more gallons of beer than the same month in 2018.[10] A major reason for this boost was lifting the state restrictions – where beer had a 3.2 percent ABV cap on beer sold in retail outlets. Notably, the Colorado cannabis industry recently broke a sales record in March 2019 – further supporting the argument that craft beer and marijuana can live together in harmony.[11]

Furthermore, this arbitrary fear pushed into the media of legal marijuana negatively affecting the beer industry is predominately Big Beer’s fear. In the past decade, Americans have experienced a change in taste regarding food and drink – with farm to fork menus, craft cocktails, and craft beer at the forefront of this change.[12] When Big Beer faced a drastic decrease in the market share, they began to unfairly influence the marketplace by purchasing ownership interest in craft breweries in order to penetrate the market and recover its lost market share.[13] Just like craft beer, Big beer also likely views legalization of marijuana a threat to its market place. Big beer has and continues to lobby against the legalization for fear of a competitive threat.[14] Therefore, it makes sense Big Beer would push against legalization for fear of losing anything more than they already have.

2.  Does Co-Existence Include the Combination?

Now that we have established the growing industries can co-exist in the world of legal intoxication, but can they be combined? In 2017, alcohol infused with hemp or cannabis became a new phenomenon and craft beer circumvented regulatory hurdles and federal prohibition by making a beer that only had cannabinoids and does not contain THC – the psychoactive property of cannabis.[15] But as of 2019, infused beverages only made up a mere 2 to 3 percent of total sales – indicating the possibility that consumers do not want to consume their cannabis the same way they consume beer.

However, the coronavirus pandemic has also impacted consumption behavior recently. As of April 2020, cannabis infused beverage sales have increased by 14%, which is a big jump for the category. The change in consumer sales is seemingly based on the fact the virus attacks the respiratory system, so consumers prefer to eat or drink their cannabis instead of smoking or vaping it.[16] Despite the recent jump in consumption of infused drinks, it is still unclear whether consumers are demanding the infusion of craft beer and cannabis – but that has not stopped Big Beer from investing.

Although most of Big Beer lives in fear of legalization, the large alcohol craft beer acquirers are taking a more progressive approach. Specifically, Big Beer has invested significant money in the cannabis industry, partnering with large legal marijuana producers to invest in cannabis beverage ventures.[17] For example, in 2018, Molson Coors took a controlling stake in a joint venture with a licensed pot producer in Canada. Anheuser-Busch InBev put $50 million toward a similar joint venture with the British Columbia-based Tilray. Lagunitas, now owned by Heineken already sells a hop-flavored, pot-infused sparkling water at marijuana dispensaries, in partnership with Sonoma’s CannaCraft. Constellation Brands, which includes Corona and Modelo, threw down nearly $4 billion — the biggest investment in the history of marijuana — on a 38 percent share in the largest Canadian marijuana producer.[18] For a market player to actively lobby against legalization, these investments beg questions of Big Beer’s intent. Most likely, the reality is Big Beer is trying to break into the market to help increase the slow, steady decline from the past couple decades. However, the logistics of doing this at a commercial level are nearly absurd, as the regulation at state and federal levels are uncertain and unclear. Thus, craft beer should not be concerned with Big Beer’s overwhelming investment. The newly formed relationship between cannabis and Big Beer seems comparable to a business executive marrying a trophy spouse – where appearances seem fun but even if it works, it will most likely be short lived. As legalization continues to change the regulatory environments in states, and eventually the federal government, the production of cannabis-infused beer is on the rise, but it will take time to see if they are here to stay.

Despite the fear peddled by Big Beer, there is no evidence to suggest craft beer and cannabis cannot co-exist in the world of legal intoxication. As consumer palates evolve and counterculture makes its way into culture, we will likely see more of the two industries working in harmony, rather than in competition. Although the change in consumption may demand more batches of cannabis-themed beer, regulatory uncertainty still remains, particularly with the combining THC with alcoholic beverages. As craft brewers and craft growers continue to advance in their innovations, it seems most reasonable for the two industries to support each other as they combat Big Beer and regulatory barriers.

[1] Hayley Peterson, Yep, Marijuana Legalization is Bad News for Beer Sales, SLATE (Dec. 7, 2016),

http://www.slate.com/blogs/business_insider/2016/12/07/beer_sales_take_a_hit_in

_states_where_marijuana_is_legal.html (“The data indicates that many beer drinkers are swapping their six-packs for marijuana instead”, then later citing that mainstream beer sales are down more than craft beer sales. Id.).

[2] Jim Tankersley, How Pot and Hippie Beer Explain the Future of the American Economy, THE WASH. POST (Nov. 7, 2015), https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/11/07/in-the-land-ofmicrobrews-and-marijuana/?utm_term=.36889bdcc11c

[3] Newman, Tyler, Escape from the Underground: Lessons to the cannabis industry from craft beer, The Growler (Mar. 27, 2018) https://growlermag.com/escape-from-the-underground-lessons-to-the-cannabis-industry-from-craft-beer/

[4] Kendall, Justin, Beer Institute Examines the Marijuana Industry During Annual Meeting (Jun. 13, 2018)   https://www.brewbound.com/news/beer-institute-examines-marijuana-industry-annual-meeting

[5] Id.

[6] Hauser, Lyle, Canada’s legalization of marijuana offers a blueprint for the U.S. (Mar. 22, 2019) https://www.statnews.com/2019/03/22/canada-legalize-marijuana-lessons-united-states/

[7] Adams, Mike, Is Legal Marijuana Hurting Beer Sales Or Helping Them? (May 21, 2019) https://www.forbes.com/sites/mikeadams/2019/05/21/is-legal-marijuana-hurting-beer-sales-or-helping-them/#6358947f47bd

[8] Id.

[9] Id.

[10] Id.

[11] Id.

[12] 5 N. DAVEY NEAL, CURRENT AND FUTURE ISSUES FACING LOCAL BREWERS AND VINTNERS (2015), 2015 WL 9875437, at *3.

[13] Eileen Faust, Fast Fact About the Merger of Anheuser-Busch InBev and SABMiller, THE MORNING CALL (Oct. 5, 2016) http://www.mcall.com/business/getsmart/mc-fast-facts-about-anheuser-buschinbev-merger-20161005-story.html; For a full list of craft breweries purchased by AB InBev, see The Cut Off – List of Imposter Craft Beer Brands, BREW STUDS, http://wearebrewstuds.com/craft-beer-cut-off/

[14] Scheherazade Daneshkhu and Lindsay Whipp, US Drinks Industry Ponders Effect of Cannabis Legalization, FINANCIAL TIMES (Nov. 25, 2016) note 105 (specifically citing Boston Beer Company, though calling themselves craft beer, as another Big Beer conglomerate).

[15] Press Release, Malkin Law, Cannabis Infused Alcohol (Feb. 14, 2017), http://www.malkinlawfirm.com/cannabis-infused-alcohol/. While hemp-infused beer is technically legal, the regulations by the federal government are abundant: This adds to the already tedious amount of regulations which brewers must face every day).

[16] Salarizadeh, Cynthia, Cannabis Consumer Behavior Alters With Covid-19 Quarantine: Edibles & Drinks Surge (April 3, 2020) https://www.greenmarketreport.com/cannabis-consumer-behavior-alters-with-covid-19-quarantine-edibles-drinks-surge/

[17] Alicia Wallace, Alcohol Goliath Pours $190M into Canadian Cannabis Company, THE CANNABIST (Oct. 30, 2017), http://www.thecannabist.co/2017/10/30/constellation-marijuana-investmentcanopy/91171/.

[18]Lewis, Amanda Chicago, Big Alcohol is pouring billions into the drinkable marijuana market. But is that how anybody wants to get high? (July 30, 2019) https://www.theverge.com/2019/7/30/18639829/weed-beer-drinkable-marijuana-cannabis-drinks-alcohol

 

Act I, Scene II: Wood v. Allen

Now this case, for me at least, is terribly confusing, because I thought, reading the cert petition, that the Court granted cert to deal with a legal question that has confused the lower courts, that is, what is the relationship between (d)(2) and (e)(1) of AEDPA? Justice Ginsburg

I agree, Ruth. This case is terribly confusing. First things first, what is “cert” and why does the court grant it? Technically, Justice Ginsburg is using cool, legal shorthand to try and seem hip and relevant to teens (hint: no one is relevant to teens). Cert is short for certiorari. When someone wants the Supremes to review their case, they ask the court. If at least four Supremes want to hear the case, they grant a “petition of certiorari;” even Justice Ginsburg realizes this is a bit stuffy.

Next up: that pesky acronym “AEDPA”: The Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act (yikes). Thankfully, Justice Sotomayor explains the act “contains two provisions governing federal-court review of state-court factual findings.” Great. It is clear what this case is about from the first sentence of the opinion. That has to be a record.

Under 28 U. S. C. §2254(d)(2), a federal court may not grant a state prisoner’s application for a writ of habeas corpus based on a claim already adjudicated on the merits in state court unless that adjudication “resulted in a decision that was based on an unreasonable determination of the facts in light of the evidence presented in the State court proceeding.” Under §2254(e)(1), “a determination of a factual issue made by a State court shall be presumed to be correct,” and the petitioner “shall have the burden of rebutting the presumption of correctness by clear and convincing evidence.”

Habeas corpus is pretty nifty. It is basically the ability for someone in state detention to ask the federal courts to make sure their confinement is legal. Translation: “Can they really hold me here like this? Like for real for real?”

In this case, petitioner, a capital defendant, challenges the key factual finding made by the Alabama state court that denied his application for postconviction relief: that his attorneys’ failure to pursue and present mitigating evidence of his borderline mental retardation was a strategic decision rather than a negligent omission. Petitioner argues that the state court’s finding was unreasonable under §2254(d)(2) and that, in denying his federal habeas petition, the Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit erroneously conflated this standard with that of §2254(e)(1), which petitioner contends is not applicable in cases, such as this one, not involving a separate federal habeas evidentiary hearing.

Woods is basically arguing that he is receiving the death penalty because his legal team chose not to pursue evidence that may have resulted in a lesser sentence. However, Woods also argues that (e)(1) would only apply to habeas cases that involve evidentiary hearings (this means the federal court would actually review new evidence and not just review the record). Evidentiary hearings are uncommon, and “less frequent after AEDPA” according to a 2007 Department of Justice-funded study.

Only 9.5% of the capital cases in the sample included an evidentiary hearing, compared to 19% prior to AEDPA. Although some of the unfinished cases in the sample could yet include evidentiary hearings, the number is unlikely to reach the rate reported prior to AEDPA.

During oral arguments, Justice Roberts said, “the problem is that (d)(2) refers to determination of facts and asks whether it’s unreasonable. (E)(1) talks about facts and has a whole different test, and I guess the difficulty I’ve had is reconciling the two.” That’s two Justices confused, for the record. Justice Breyer asked counsel to give “an example where you’re trying to proceed under (d)(2), and (e)(1) is somehow relevant.” General Maze gives and example and Justice Breyer is having none of it, saying, “No. You just look at them, and you look under (d)(2), and you say this is an unreasonable determination of fact, period. There’s no reason to go into (e)(1). I mean, if it is an unreasonable determination of fact, he wins. And if it isn’t, you win.”

General Maze fires back, “The reason that you go under (e)(1) is because Congress has said that you have to.”

Justice Breyer volleys, “It didn’t say that. What it says in (e)(1) is (e)(1) is talking about in a proceeding instituted by an application by a person in custody, the factual issue is presumed correct. But if you fail to develop — you know, in a proceeding, it’s presumed correct. You’re right it doesn’t say it literally. But I can’t figure out an application for it unless they’re talking about where there is a new hearing. Otherwise there is just no need for it, it is just repetitive and it gets people mixed up, and (d)(2) does all the work.”

During the recorded oral arguments for this case, three Justices clearly stated confusion. Not indecision, not moral ambiguity, pure and simple doctrinal confusion. So, do the Supremes take this opportunity to clarify how these two aspects of the law interact?

We granted certiorari to address the relationship between §§2254(d)(2) and (e)(1). We conclude, however, that the state court’s factual determination was reasonable even under petitioner’s reading of §2254(d)(2), and therefore we need not address that provision’s relationship to §2254(e)(1).

No they do not.

 

Five-Four is one of my favorite podcasts. I look forward to Peter, Rhiannon, and Michael cracking jokes and skulls (parody! parody! parody!) each week. One tiny seed they planted in my brain is about Justice Ginsberg. Maybe she is a complex human being (aka fallible), not a super-powered elder fighting injustice. Maybe Notorious R.B.G, RBG, and On the Basis of Sex have oversimplified her story. (Review: The Danger of a Single Story).

One of the hosts made an off-hand comment (what is an on-hand comment?) about how Justice Sotomayor is probably the strongest writer and most solid in terms of jurisprudence. So, I’ve started a quest. I’m going back in time to listen to oral arguments and read through the opinions authored by Justice Sotomayor in hopes that I can glean some wisdom and improve my writing.

Listen to arguments at Oyez.
Read through opinions at Justia.

Act I, Scene I: Mohawk Industries, Inc. v. Carpenter

Our first stop involves the world’s largest flooring manufacturer, allegations of employing undocumented immigrants, and the disclosure of information protected by attorney-client privilege.

The question before us is whether disclosure orders adverse to the attorney-client privilege qualify for immediate appeal under the collateral order doctrine. Agreeing with the Court of Appeals, we hold that they do not. Postjudgment appeals, together with other review mechanisms, suffice to protect the rights of litigants and preserve the vitality of the attorney-client privilege.

Listening to oral arguments, I am reminded that improvisation is an essential skill during appeals.

Reading through the opinion, I found a gift. Order from the chaos, structure among the murkiness of Scalia, Alito, or Uncle Umpire himself. This case was unanimous (9-0) and so clearly skipped on the podcast. It is an interesting question: can the world’s largest flooring manufacturer immediately appeal the district court’s decision to compel them to provide Carpenter with information from his meeting with their counsel about his allegations the company was employing undocumented immigrants? In a word: no.

Permitting piecemeal, prejudgment appeals, we have recognized, undermines “efficient judicial administration” and encroaches upon the prerogatives of district court judges, who play a “special role” in managing ongoing litigation. Firestone Tire & Rubber Co. v. Risjord

Ah yes, my old nemesis: judicial efficiency. While deciding the other way may have been disruptive to the judicial system, I think the pandemic offers great insight: the system will not change without major disruptive events.

MI trial courts have made a pretty incredible transition in the last four months. Probably more than in the last two decades. Michigan Chief Justice Bridget Mary McCormack on Legal Talk Network

P.s. What about the alleged employment of undocumented immigrants to lower wages? In 2012, Mohawk settled a class-action suit for $18 million.

 

 

My Host Organization: Inland Counties Legal Services, inc.

This summer, I had an opportunity to work with Inland Counties Legal Services, Inc. (ICLS), a Legal Service organization located in Riverside, California, through ATJ Tech Fellowship Program. Because of the pandemic, the internship was conducted fully remotely so I stayed in New Hampshire but worked with people in California. Still, it was a great experience working on a new type of legal work (legal tech) in a new way other than in an office, and meeting with new people on the other side of the country.

 

 “Inland Counties Legal Services, Inc. pursues justice and equality for low-income people through counsel, advice, advocacy, and community education, treating all with dignity and respect.”

 

ICLS is a non-profit 501(c)(3) corporation serving Riverside and San Bernardino Counties. They serve people who are in need of legal help, but who cannot afford attorney costs. Also, ICLS helps people who are trying to represent themselves in court without hiring an attorney, so they can be prepared for the case even without representation.

 

Among several practice groups in ICLS, I worked with the Consumer Team. Consumer Team has three sub-groups: Finance, Tax, and Bankruptcy. Finance team mostly deals with consumer debts, including PACE (Property Assessed Clean Energy program) cases, medical debts, and credit card debts. Tax team runs LITC (Low-Income Taxpayers Clinic) helping low income people who are in dispute with the IRS (Internal Revenue Service), and Bankruptcy team deals with consumer bankruptcy cases, mostly of chapter 7 and 13.

 

The project I participated in, is building interviews on HotDocs *, uploading those interviews on the LHI (LawHelp Interactive) website **, and connecting the database between the interviews on LHI and ICLS case management system. Consumer Team is trying to make automated interviews for about 40 types of documents, so that the interviewers from ICLS and other pro bono attorneys can conduct the interviews in the same structure, and easily generate documents from the automated process. This project started at the same time I began my internship in June, thus I had an opportunity to observe the project meetings and its beginning progress while interning. It is planned to be completed by the end of 2021.

 

I learned that this kind of project is one of efficient ways to conduct client interviews, but there are not many automated interviews or forms that can be used by self-helpers without a lawyer or by professionals for their clients. Although this is a quite long-term project, I hope this project will help legal professionals and self-helpers in California when it is all completed.

 

 

* HotDocs is document automation, generation, and assembly software

 

** LawHelp Interactive (LHI) is a “website that helps you fill out legal documents for free.”

 

 

This summer, I participated in Passport to Practice. The focus was on competencies outside of legal know-how needed for success in the legal profession. It was great! I felt vindicated (I am selfish, I am wrong). But one major take-away? So. Much. Jargon.

For instance: valuation. What does that even mean? According to Oxford Dictionary, valuation is “an estimation of something’s worth, especially one carried out by a professional appraiser.” Since I’m not a professional appraiser, I’m going to think about valuation as: what do I value and why?

Step 1: Choose Your Big 8. Which values from chart below resonate to you when it comes to your career? Initially, I found myself making arguments for adopting as many of the poor, defenseless values as I could. (Note: not a helpful exercise). My Big 8 are:

  • Accountability;
  • Adventure;
  • Compassion;
  • Diversity;
  • Enjoyment/Fun;
  • Flexibility;
  • Generosity; and
  • Learning.
Advancement Competency Enjoyment/Fun Efficiency Security
Adventure Individuality Loyalty Dignity Influence
Aesthetics Equality Credibility Collaboration Learning
Affiliation Integrity Honesty Stewardship Compassion
Artistic Creativity Service Innovativeness Empathy Friendliness
Diversity Responsibility Teamwork Accomplishment Discipline/Order
Autonomy Accuracy Excellence Courage Generosity
Meaningful
Work
Respect Accountability Wisdom Persistence
Moral
Fulfillment
Dedication Empowerment Security Optimism
Physical
Challenge
Improvement Quality Dependability Flexibility

Step 2: Apply Those Critical Thinking Skills, Work Edition. Why do you work? What defines worthwhile work? How does it related to the individual, others, and society? What does money have to do with work? What do experience, growth, and fulfillment have to do with work?

These questions are basic… and tricky. Why I work? Capitalism means I need resources to obtain Maslow’s staples: food, water, and shelter. I have to work to survive. Oddly, survival is not one of my Big 8. I like to work, too, especially when I get to help someone figure something out. Like when a student and I talked through a math problem. The student needed a different perspective, a translation of the instructions, and someone they felt safe asking for help. Or when I helped someone complete the gauntlet of obtaining their food handling certification (5 hours and $47 dollars later). I work because vulnerable people are being taken advantage of everywhere. It’s just not right and I have the opportunity to try and do something about it.

Step 3: Apply Those Critical Thinking Skills, Life Edition. What is the purpose of life? What is the relationship between individual and others? Where do family, country, and the rest of the world fit in? What is the role of joy, sorrow, justice, injustice, love, peace, and strife in your life?

Step 4: Find the Rub. Where do your views on work and life complement one another? Where do they clash? Does one drive the other (and if so, how)?

I honestly was not expecting such a deep dive. Why aren’t these conversations happening as part of law school? Why is thinking about my life, how my values impact my work, not part of law school?

< Hwang, Ji Hye>

 

Ji Hye is a J.D. Candidate at University of New Hampshire, Franklin Pierce School of Law.

She graduated from Ewha Womans University, South Korea, in 2017. Her undergraduate major was English Language and Literature; she double-majored in Digital Humanities (Scranton Honor’s Program), and also minored in Computer Science and Engineering as a part of SCSC program. SCSC stands for Samsung Convergence Software Course, which was a certification program for non-engineering students to promote software education. Ji Hye also studied Filmmaking at Stephens College, MO, during the 2014-2015 academic year as an exchange student.

Ji Hye is mainly interested in Copyright and Trademarks law. She is willing to learn more about Immigration and Consumer law as well.

 

This blog post is a response to a design-thinking and race-based advocacy challenge for the Access to Justice Tech Fellowship.

“In all too many cases, I had the sense that if only the immigrant had competent counsel at the very outset of immigration proceedings… the outcome might have been different, the noncitizen might have prevailed.”

– Chief Judge Robert A. Katzmann, Second Circuit Court of Appeals

Immigrants in removal proceedings have a statutory right to counsel. Unlike criminal defendants, however, indigent immigrants are not given government-funded counsel and instead must obtain representation at their own expense. Without an attorney, immigrants represent themselves in extremely complex proceedings. Even children in removal proceedings are expected to represent themselves if they can’t afford a lawyer or find a pro bono lawyer.

There are amazing organizations that offer free legal services, like Keep Tucson Together and the Florence Immigrant and Refugee Rights Project. However, Bill Ong Hing, author of this Slate article that calls for government-funded representation, emphasizes that:

“There is simply not enough legal aid and pro bono help available for those who need it.”

So without government-funded representation, most immigrant respondents appear pro se.

The American Immigration Council reports that, based on data collected from 2007-2012, only 37% of all immigrants in removal proceedings had counsel. And just 14% of detained immigrants had counsel during this same period. Immigrants with hearings in small cities were the least likely to have representation.

We know that immigrants with representation have better outcomes.

For example, the same AIC report states that detained immigrants with counsel were 4x as likely to be released from detention than pro se detained immigrants.

In 2011, New York City piloted a pro bono agency that provided free deportation defense. According to the New York Times, “immigrants in the Varick Street Immigration Court are now 11 times more likely to win their cases than before the program began.” This program is now fully funded and, by 2017, the “rate of success — defined as the immigrant’s being allowed to stay in the United States — had risen by 1,100 percent.”

This means that there are wildly disparate outcomes depending on if you can find and afford to hire an attorney.

I’ve been thinking about this a lot in the last several weeks in relation to my fellowship project evaluating the use of video teleconferencing (VTC) technology in immigration courts (for more on this, see my previous post!).

For my project, I’m interviewing attorneys who represent immigrants detained at La Palma Correctional Center about their experiences with hearings conducted over VTC. I’ve heard some horrifying things about their experiences, which will no doubt be the subject of a future blog post. I keep wondering, though, about pro se immigrant respondents. If attorneys are reporting terrible hearings where judges mute immigrants’ VTC feeds or make verbally abusive remarks to the attorneys, what are these VTC hearings like for immigrants without legal counsel?

Pima County must follow New York City’s lead and create an Office of Immigration Representation to ensure that Pima County residents are not forced to go through complicated immigration proceedings alone. 

A system can’t purport to promise full and fair hearings without guaranteeing government-funded representation, especially when we know that outcomes vary significantly based on access to representation.

The Pima County Justice for All campaign reports that last year a staggering 98% of immigrants appearing at the Tucson Immigration Court did not have representation:

“Last year, close to 24,000 cases were processed through Tucson Immigration Court. Of those cases, 98% of people did not have a lawyer to help represent and defend them in court. These are not unknown individuals, these are families, friends, and neighbors who have been in the area, paying into our tax systems and helping build our communities, for years. Our friends are entitled to proper representation and support.”

An Office of Immigration Representation, funded by Pima County, would eradicate the disparities between immigrants with and without counsel. No one should be deported because they can’t afford a lawyer (maybe no one should be deported at all, but that’s a conversation for another day).

When I received an offer to intern for an organization that advocates for the protection of civil liberties, I felt a little like a middle schooler whose mom scored tickets to see the Jonas Brothers circa 2007. My mom never got me tickets to see the Jonas Brothers, something I don’t hold against her, but I knew classmates who went and I’m drawing on their experience here.

Then, adding to my excitement, I also was given the amazing opportunity to be a fellow in the Access to Justice Tech Fellowship program.

I am so unbelievably thankful for the opportunity to learn about lawyering from my host organization and to have the extra fellowship curriculum enhance my summer. As an A2J Tech Fellow, I am spending my summer working on a project for my host organization that centers on access to justice and technology.

My fellowship project focuses on evaluating the use of video teleconferencing (VTC) technology in immigration courts. VTC use has become increasingly common, with Ingrid V. Eagly reporting in her 2015 law review article that one-third of all detained immigrants appear for their hearings over VTC. Proponents argue that VTC makes courts more accessible, speeds judicial processes, and reduces court costs. However, many are concerned that VTC usage raises due process issues, from interfering with the detainee’s ability to confer confidentially with their attorney to technology-related delays to judges making credibility determinations off of a grainy or pixelated video feed (check out this article from the ABA Journal or this report from the Young Center for Immigrant Children’s Rights for more on this).

Side note: this topic has suddenly become even more relevant with courts not holding in-person hearings due to the pandemic. See the below video for a jury trial over VTC!

 

I live in Tucson, Arizona, about an hour from the La Palma Correctional Center (LPCC) where numerous immigrants are detained.

“It’s a dry heat!” – everyone in Tucson

Many LPCC detainees appear at the Tucson Immigration Court over VTC, unlike the detained immigrants at the Florence or Eloy detention centers who appear in person at courts on-site. The detained immigrants’ attorneys, if they have one, must choose between appearing from LPCC with their clients or being in the courtroom with the judge.

Originally, I was supposed to coordinate a court observation program in which volunteers would observe VTC hearings at the Tucson Immigration Court and document due process issues. I was excited to do some preliminary data analysis and write a report at the end of the summer explaining what we’d learned so far. This program was meant to outlive my summer internship and facilitate long-term data collection. Unfortunately, COVID-19 complicated these plans, forcing us to postpone the observation program and pivot for the time being.

Instead, my project took on two new forms. First, I am writing a memo analyzing due process challenges to immigration courts’ use of VTC. Second, I am interviewing attorneys who have represented clients detained at LPCC to learn more about their experiences with VTC. Eventually, when Arizona is no longer a COVID hotspot, hopefully we’ll be able to start the court observation program.

This project will inform immigration advocates of widespread violations and help them ensure that all individuals receive due process. It will help hold public officials accountable and improve courts’ procedures and technology use.

This VTC project is designed to make sure that every immigrant receives the full and fair hearing they are statutorily entitled to. I also want to acknowledge that the fight is bigger than this. Yes, every immigrant should have a full and fair hearing, AND they also should not be detained or subject to deportation at all. This project is at the both/and intersection of the “here we are” and the “not yet.” Massive changes need to be made and systems must be dismantled. And, also, here we are, in the moment, working to ensure that, as these big changes are made, those caught in the here and now are given the rights they are promised.  This summer I’m learning to lean into this tension; to work on improving what is in front of me while also remembering that the fight is bigger.

At the middle point of my fellowship and project, I’ve been reflecting on this: as soon to be lawyers, we must pay attention to the ways in which the legal system dehumanizes and hurts and oppresses. We must bear witness to the atrocities happening every day in immigration detention and courts, and we must use our new power, privilege, and skills to respond.

As all of you may know, divorce is expensive. In Colorado, the average cost of divorce without children is $14,500 (9th highest in the nation) and the average cost of divorce with children is $21,700 (10th highest in the nation). The goal for my summer project with A2J Tech is to make divorce in Colorado more affordable for everyone. But to properly do that, I need to understand my target demographic; the people who are more likely to divorce but do not have the financial capabilities to do so.

Demographic Characteristic of the Target Audience: Class

The socioeconomic divisions based on educational attainment.

Unfortunately, the expense of divorce boils down to a class issue due to the financial barrier many people need to overcome when considering divorcing their partner. The most well-known indicator of financial success depends on one’s educational attainment; the highest level of education completed. Those who completed a bachelor’s degree or higher end up in the lower middle class or higher, while those who had some college credits or only high school experience end up in the working class and lower class. Interestingly, one’s educational attainment also determines the success of one’s first marriage as well.

In fact, people with a bachelor’s degree or graduate degree and people who were fortunate enough to be born in affluent families tend to enjoy relatively strong and stable marriages, while the working class and the lower class are less likely to get and stay married. In a study on marriages and divorces following people born during 1957-1964 until 2010, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics found that “[t]he chance of a marriage ending in divorce was lower for people with more education, with over half of marriages of those who did not complete high school having ended in divorce compared with approximately 30 percent of marriages of college graduates.” Surprisingly, the people who can afford a divorce attorney statistically do not need one.

Demographic Characteristic of the Target Audience: Race

Although the financial burden of divorce is shared among all racial, ethnic, and religious groups within the working and lower class, it is important to discuss how minorities are disproportionately affected by this burden. In the same study, researchers found that Black Americans married later and at lower rates compared to White and Asian Americans, but those that do end up marrying, about 47.9% of the first marriages result in divorce. For Latino Americans, 45.5% of first marriages result in divorce.

When taking a quick glance at the statistics, there is slight increase for minorities who do end up divorcing from their first marriages. However, this study emphasizes how one’s education level leads to a more stable first marriage, with 29.8% of first marriages of people with a bachelor’s degree resulting in divorce. The group who attained a bachelor’s degree was made up of a majority of White Americans and some Asian Americans.

Today, the composition of Americans who were able to get a bachelor’s degree or higher remains the same. In a 2015 Census study on Educational Attainment in the United States, people who earned a bachelor’s degree or higher is composed of 53.9% Asian, 32.8% White, 22.5% Black, and 15.5% Latino. These statistics show how systematic racism and systematic poverty affect minorities in America; I think it is important to note these as two of the biggest causes for such low percentages of higher educational attainment among Black and Latino Americans.

As you can see from these statistics, lower income minorities tend to be more likely to divorce and are more likely not to afford the legal services to divorce. So, the financial burden of divorce not only affects people of lower socioeconomic status, but disproportionately affects poor Black and Latino Americans.

How Would Our Project Improve the Lives of the Target Audience?

The goal of the Colorado Divorce Project, now in partnership with Hello Divorce, is to alleviate the financial burden of divorce for everyone. We are automating the divorce forms in Colorado, to make it easier for someone to fill out all the legal forms required to file for divorce without the attorney price tag. For more information about the Colorado Divorce Project, please check out my previous blog post. Remarkably, this project will benefit people who belong to lower socioeconomic classes and minority communities the most since they are disproportionately impacted by the legal fees of divorce. It will not only make divorce more accessible to lower classes but make the financial burden easier to overcome for everyone facing such a life changing issue.

If you ask Googs, it says a primer is “an elementary textbook that serves as an introduction to a subject of study or is used for teaching children to read.” An introduction. A place to start. Training. It’s easy to feel overwhelmed when there is a lot happening – pandemic, protest, violence, political incompetence. Sometimes it has been a relief to divert my attention to automated document assembly and sometimes it has been just as overwhelming.

Welcome to the world of…

A very poor rendition of a very famous logo.
Tweets flying through majestic digital skies, Quip scales keeping the beast organized, GitHub cat/octopus and Docassemble cat crowding out the forest of Slack chatter.

I may, or may not, have spent an inappropriate amount of time creating a parody logo… out of logos. Why? Because over the past few months, I have been inundated with tools. They are a cluttered mess, just like the abomination above. There has been a distinct absence of primer. Below, I’ve drafted an overview of what the heck each of these things are, how I’ve used them, and what I still don’t understand. Because it’s a lot.

  • Zoom
    • How I’ve Zoomed: video calls, live chat, hand raising, polling, white boards, screen sharing, break-out rooms. It is almost ready to form a committee to solve homelessness.
    • Zoom Success: First Generation Support Group sessions! We’ve been able to continue meeting regularly despite pandemic, relocation, and summer employment. I look forward to seeing everyone each month. We all have no idea what we’re doing and we keep showing up and struggling along. They keep me going!
    • Zooming Questions:
      • Do I currently have end-to-end encryption or not? “We plan to begin early beta of the E2EE feature in July 2020.” So, not yet? Read more on Zoom blog.
      • How do I setup a meeting so that people can add it to their calendars?
      • If private chat messages aren’t viewable to the host, why do my classmates think they are?
      • How did Skype, Hangouts, and all the other virtual conference/webinar platforms whiff so mightily? What happened?
      • Virtual Meeting Etiquette? The Googs returned over 4 million results (versus only 1.4 million for “uranium contaminated groundwater”). People! Prioritize!
Raise the white flag of defeat when it comes to staring at a screen all day.
Zoom Fatigue. Look for it in the DSM-VI.

 

  • Slack
    • How I’ve Slacked: team and group communication, email alternative, access to archive of prior communication, access to network outside of organization roster, managing multiple “workspaces” feels awkward at the user level.
    • Slack Success: I really like having access to the prior communication. Want to catch up on a project? Just read through what Jenny posted last year. Gives helpful context to framing questions, especially when just starting out.
    • Slacking Questions:
      • Why would I ever want to enable notifications? Yuck.
      • Is this an efficient way to communicate or just a different way?
      • Can I have a slimmed down version? Ideally, one feature. A tutorial mode to unlock other features. Otherwise, it’s very much deep end of the pool.
      • How are these communications stored/archived/logged? How are the data used by the company? When am I going to receive targeted adds for Champlain College online?
Beaver drinking Fizze, eating flavored corn chips, and playing a video game console. It is marvelous.
Note: this is not the official branding for the tool. I think they really lost an opportunity. Plus, now I know this beaver also enjoys flavored corn chips.

At this point, I’ve only briefly highlighted two of them. I’m exhausted. I also wrote down Quip, GitHub, Documate, Docassemble, A2J, and Twitter, but this is starting to get cumbersome. I don’t think a blog is the right place for a primer.