Examining the etymology of a word can reveal a lot about the relationships it has with other ideas. If you’re in a relationship, a significant milestone is meeting the parents of your romantic partner. As you get to know your partner’s parents you learn more about your partner. Likewise, a word is born from a specific cultural and historical context. How a word has been shaped and changed over time can also give clues about the values and ideas informing the context we currently inhabit.

Evolution of equityThe word equity (n.), like most of our legal words, comes to us from Latin through Old French. The Latin term aequitas (n. f. nom. sing.) entered Old French and became equite which over the march of history eventually became the English equity.1 The Latin root of the word aequitas is aequus (adj.) which means “level, even, equal, like, just, kind, favorable, impartial, fair, patient, contented.2” Aequus is also where we get the English word equal (adj.)3.

There are three things to note here. First, the root Latin word aequus and the subsequent English word equal are adjectives. They describe something. They can also be adverbs describing an action. For example: “Judge Posner ruled equitably.” Only later did these terms become nouns perhaps after being associated with the procedural institutions that now bear their name. Even when they are nouns, they still serve as modifiers of another term. For example, “She wants equity.” Inevitably, what our hypothetical person wants is for something to be equitable. It is a feature of English grammar to turn descriptive words into nouns. That in turn can distort our understanding of the terms themselves by making them objects abstracted from the realities in which they adhere.

Grammatical diagram of equitySecond, even when we use the term as an adjective or adverb, the word is rooted in physical metaphor. The most tangible is the metaphor of even ground. This is conceptually related to the idea of similarity. The ground is level when it is uniform or similar. By abstraction, we think of a game as equitable when it is on a “level playing field.” When there is no slant towards one side. As a bizarre coincidence, the term inequitable has its origin in the Latin word inequabilis which is rooted in the similar-sounding term equus which means “horse.” For the ground to be inequitable also meant it was impassable for a horse4.

Diagram of logical distinction of justice, equity, and equalityThird, equity is related, both conceptually and grammatically, to equality. Likewise, they are conceptually related and similar in grammatical function to the term justice. However, they are also distinct. As we explore the history of equity more fully we will see how to distinguish these concepts and terms more precisely. Initially, it is worth noting justice is more extensive and contains equity, while equality overlaps the two while not being contained by either5.

Next time we will look at the history of equity in the legal system.


1. Etymonline: equity
Back to text.

2. Oxford, Latin Desk Dictionary, 7 (2005)
Back to text.

3. Etymonline: equal
Back to text.

4. Etymonline: inequitable
Back to text.

5. E1 = Equity, J = Justice, and E2 = Equality. (E1 ⊂ J) | (E2 ∪ E1) | (E2 ∪  J) where E1 ≠ J ∧ ∀x, x ∈ E1 ⇒ x ∈ J. 
Back to text.

 

Most law students will admit that law school is no easy feat. We all have our own set of circumstances that impact our ability to focus, navigate and ultimately succeed.

Finances, physical health, mental health, “imposter syndrome,” educational deficiencies, proximity to campus are just some of the factors I have witnessed peers having to grapple with on their journey to the Bar. Yet so many of us do not have access to help or we choose not to ask for help. Possibly for fear of being judged.

Law students are supposed to have it all together, right? Wrong.

I will never forget the sinking feeling in the pit of my stomach, when I finally accepted the fact, I would have to take a leave of absence from law school so I could focus on motherhood and financing our livelihood. When I became pregnant, I was a fulltime law student working fulltime; I had just returned home from a summer externship in Alaska. I had been voted into leadership positions and was selected to write on a legal journal.

I was ready to finish law school, and then, boom, LIFE happened. I found out I was pregnant. I decided to make some lifestyle changes. For one, I would not be able to continue working night shifts as a hotel auditor who would sometimes leave a nightshift, grab breakfast, and head directly to school with little to no sleep, just riding on fumes. That was not going to be healthy for the baby. We also decided it would be best for our family to move to a new neighborhood.

There was so much we had to factor in, so much to budget for; it became clear that law school was no longer within our budget. Although I took a leave of absence from law school, I began to work at a firm as a legal administrator so I could keep my skills sharp and stay immersed in the legal field. I never gave up on my dream of returning to law school, obtaining my Juris Doctorate degree, and becoming an attorney.

My daughter is the light of my life and my reason why. She is worth every sacrifice. Being a mother has brought me more joy than anything I have ever done in this world. Knowing that my child was with me (in my womb) as I took those bus rides to work as a legal administrator in downtown Seattle kept me moving forward. I have witnessed peers of mine graduate and ascend into the legal profession. Although it would have been “ideal” to complete my legal education years ago, it was not in the cards for me. Motherhood has taught me that we all have different paths on this journey, and I happen to be on the “road less travelled.”

As a first-generation college student, money has always been an issue.

Prior to law school, my family experienced a death that rocked us to the core emotionally and financially. Yet, we carried on because we have always carried on. Once I made it to law school, I was scrambling to keep up. I had to work extra hours just to pay for older edition textbooks and “professional clothes.” Super grateful for the law library and peers who had my back. And prayer. I would not have made it through my first year of law school without these resources.

There was a point where I accepted that I would never return to law school, and then I decided this was unacceptable because my lack of finances could never outweigh my passion for advocacy…

Manifest your dreams. Several months before I was re-enrolled in school, I began to review my 1L outlines, read case briefs, flip through my flash cards. Listening to the oral arguments in McGirt v Oklahoma “did it” for me. I had to go back to school, some way, somehow. So… I saved my money, I applied for scholarships, and I kept hope alive.

I am now back in law school. It has been somewhat challenging readjusting to the rigor, especially in the midst of a pandemic with a toddler in tow, yet I must keep it moving.

 

ADVICE FOR THOSE OF YOU WHO HAVE TAKEN A LEAVE OF ABSENCE FROM LAW SCHOOL AND PLAN TO RETURN AT SOME POINT:

  1. Remember who YOU are and WHY you set out on this journey in the first place
  2. Meet with a mentor, financial adviser, or a trusted peer to develop a plan
  3. Apply for scholarships
  4. Build credit and look into student loans such as Sallie Mae
  5. Stay immersed within legal field (e.g. legal administration, volunteer at mock trials)
  6. Keep in contact with your legal network via social media, occasional email, Zoom meeting, etc.
  7. Never stop reading and retaining legal material
  8. Come back full throttle, but don’t forget work-life balance

So much can change in the blink of an eye…

This time last year, I was working for lawyers, however, this year, I am working to become a lawyer.

Like so many other law students and legal professionals, my journey has not been one of perfection, rather, it has been a journey of progression. For those of you who have been caught off-guard by life circumstances, REMAIN RESIIENT REGARDLESS.

As I get ready to wrap this semester, the pressure is building up. Yet, this time I know I can and will get through it.

 

I hope I make my daughter proud.

 

“Women belong in all places where decisions are being made. It shouldn’t be that women are the exception.”    ― Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg

 

McGeorge’s parent university, University of the Pacific, is ramping up its planning for the spring semester. These efforts made me curious about the national landscape: How are law schools responding to the pandemic in terms of conducting classes in person or online and what has worked to promote student, faculty, and staff safety? I sent an email survey to my colleagues asking three questions: (1) If you are holding in person class this fall (Hyflex or otherwise), what has been the key to you doing so successfully? (2) If you are online this fall, are you planning to be in person (Hyflex or otherwise) or online (in the spring)? (3) If you have not decided whether to be in person or online, when do you anticipate making a decision?

Seventy-nine of my 204 dean colleagues responded, which, in my experience, is a very high response rate, and their responses were interesting enough that I decided to share them via this posting. I have organized my report in three subtopics. In the first section, I will share a summary of the health and safety and other strategies my dean colleagues thought were most effective. In the second section, I will share the results regarding spring 2021 plans. A final section wraps up this post with final thoughts.

The Health and Safety Strategies that Seem to Have Worked

At least among the deans who chose to respond to my survey, law schools seem to have been able to avoid the major outbreaks seen at a number of undergraduate institutions. My hypothesis it that this result is a function of the age and maturity of law students and, perhaps, the fact that they are entering a field that, in effect, celebrates rules.

At most of the law schools, in-person classes were taught in some variation of the Hyflex model in which some students are in person and others are simultaneously participating online. However, at least two law school chose to have classes be either entirely in person or entirely online. At both, faculty took on temporarily-increased teaching loads so that social distancing protocols could be followed.

Nearly all law schools deferred to individual faculty preferences as to whether their classes would be in person and Hyflex or online. Law schools also were fairly uniform in allowing students to choose classes based in part on whether their classes would be at least partially in person or would be entirely online.

Overwhelmingly, my dean colleagues reported that having unambiguous rules and defined enforcement systems regarding face coverings, social distancing, daily self-screening, testing and tracing all played a significant role. They also cited training of both faculty and students as critical. Most of my colleagues emphasized the critical importance of testing classroom sound systems and having student tech and Zoom assistants in managing the challenge of simultaneously teaching students in person and online. At most of the responding law schools, class schedules were more staggered than normal to reduce student hallway interactions.

Less uniform but quite credible to me were recommendations of see-through masks for the professors and lavalier microphones.

Plans for the Spring

With only two exceptions, all of the responding law schools are following the same plans for the fall as they followed for the spring. In addition, all but one responding law school has already announced its plans for the spring semester. However, most of the responding deans noted that their announced plans were subject to the dictates of local health authorities and developments in cases, hospitalizations, and deaths as a result of the pandemic.

The final tallies: 54 of the 79 (68%) responding deans report that their classes will be partially in person, and the other 25 (32%) will be online. No law school will be entirely in person; in fact, most will have between 1/3 and 2/3 of classes online. Even among those law schools that will be otherwise entirely online, most have adopted a partial exception for legal clinics and externship sites that need to be in person to serve their clients. Interestingly, California law schools are over-represented among the law schools that will be entirely online.

Final Thoughts

There is a risk that my sample was non-representative. Perhaps the deans who did not respond did not enjoy as much success as those who did. It is also possible that the deans who did respond framed their responses to put their law schools in the best possible light. I certainly did not check any publicly reported health outcomes data for any of the law schools or their parent universities. Thus, it would be fair to read this post with a degree of skepticism.

I do wish to share one, final thought. It might be surprising to some non-deans that my colleagues were so responsive and so helpful in sharing their experiences. I believe the dean readers of this blog, however, are not at all surprised. I suspect that, if tested, we would be characterized as a fairly competitive group of people, but we nevertheless are also quite supportive of each other. We appreciate the challenges of each others’ jobs and help where we can. My final thought, therefore, is an expression of gratitude for my dean colleagues.

I. Introduction

There is a crisis of attention according to Matthew Crawford. Today, it’s a well-worn cliche that we are in an age of ever-increasing distraction. Many, if not most of us start on tasks only to be interrupted by a series of distracting notifications or internal itches to look at social media or other digital enticements. Those of us in the legal profession have a special obligation to make sure we pay attention to what is relevant. The purpose of this blog is to understand this new digital beast we find ourselves on. Ultimately, the food of this monster is data. If we want to steer it towards some semblance of justice, we need to get a handle on how it works, and how the law can or could reign it in. It’s either that or get swallowed up without even realizing it. That’s why I first want to lay the groundwork on understanding data and how it relates to equity.

This is an extensive topic with many dynamic parts. Each of these pieces could easily be a book on its own. Nevertheless, I think it is important for interested people to understand the framework I am using, even if it is ultimately incomplete.

The method we are going to use will examine the following: (1) the etymology of terms; (2) the history of the concept; (3) the functional definition; and (4) the application. The general framework I use is Aristotelean. Everything that exists has a cause. For Aristotle, there are four types of causes: (a) material, (b) efficient, (c) formal, and (d) final. (See Physics, 194b-195b, Aristotle, from The Complete Works of Aristotle edited by Jonathan Barnes, Sixth edition 1995). Etymology and history roughly correspond to the efficient cause or how it came to be. The definition more pertains to the form, essence, and matter of a subject. Thus, part of that is usually situating it in the genus and species. Finally, the analysis of the application deals with the effect and telos of a subject. The ultimate reason and goal for even discussing an idea.

All words retain the echo of history. In order to see things clearly, the lenses we use must be clean and firmly grounded. To be firmly grounded means to be rooted in history. Otherwise, everything will just be a blur. The tradition of looking at the origin of words stretches back thousands of years to at least the time of Plato. (See Cratylus, 404c, Plato, from Plato The Collected Dialogues, edited by Edith Hamilton and Huntington Cairns, twentieth edition, 2009). By better understanding the past we can then look to shape the future.

Next week we will begin by looking at the etymology of equity.

Act I, Scene III: Milavetz, Gallop & Milavetz, P. A. v. United States

I am blessed with an artistic family. We are creative, brilliant, and socially awkward because of our unique perspective. Pondering connections between ideas or exploring issues from multiple angles is just the natural process of art making. Growing up, my sister loved drawing and naturally wanted to be a drawer (definition: noun; one who draws). I wanted to be a counter! Thanks to the Milavetz decision, every child wanting to grow up to be a debt relief agency can pursue their dream!

Sonia begins each opinion with a concise roadmap: topic area, issue presented, and decision. Normally, the game is “figure out the issue, the rule, the holding” blah blah blah. Sonia knows that I have limited time on this world. She knows that I want to use this decision for justice, if I’m able. So, she’s given me a cheat sheet. Thanks, buddy!

Congress enacted the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005 (BAPCPA or Act) to correct perceived abuses of the bankruptcy system. Among the reform measures the Act implemented are a number of provisions that regulate the conduct of “debt relief agenc[ies]”—i.e., professionals who provide bankruptcy assistance to consumer debtors. See 11 U. S. C. §§101(3), (12A). These consolidated cases present the threshold question whether attorneys are debt relief agencies when they provide qualifying services. Because we agree with the Court of Appeals that they are, we must also consider whether the Act’s provisions governing debt relief agencies’ advice to clients, §526(a)(4), and requiring them to make certain disclosures in their advertisements, §§528(a) and (b)(2), violate the First Amendment rights of attorneys. Concluding that the Court of Appeals construed §526(a)(4) too expansively, we reverse its judgment that the provision is unconstitutionally overbroad. Like the Court of Appeals, we uphold §528’s disclosure requirements as applied in these consolidated cases.

Pause!

Without going any further in the opinion, do you know what you’re getting into? Most opinions do not follow this approach. Why? Honestly, I blame Cardozo. Moving on!

At oral arguments, the phrase “in contemplation of bankruptcy” was badmintoned around like some sort of high class dinner party (or at least what I assume might happen at fancy dinner parties). Milavetz basically argued that attorneys were barred from giving any advice that would result in the client incurring any additional debt, even if that advice might be completely ethical in other contexts. There was also concern about having to advertise the bankruptcy firm as providing debt relief agency services (the statute gives specific language to use).

At this point you might be thinking, “are these really the sorts of issues that need to be resolved by the United States Supreme Court?!” I see your exasperation and raise you because the Supremes hear cases that a majority of the justices have chosen to hear. They wanted to decide this issue. Plenty of injustice issues existed in 2010; determining whether or not lawyers are debt relief agencies that need to use specific language in their advertisements was the crucial issue the court decided to tackle.

Later on in the arguments Justice Ginsburg says:

Why don’t we say, well, whatever it means in 707(b), it also means in 5, whatever it is.

Civil Procedure Queen, Lover of Rules, “I Find Technicalities And Have The Glasses to Prove It” Ginsburg can’t keep track of the two codes in the argument? Honestly, this sounds like I’m sitting on the court. However, at least she made an effort. Scalia was in wonderful Scalia form:

Now, it may be a stupid law, but I don’t see why it’s unconstitutional… [s]o it’s a stupid law… [a]nd that’s why it’s a stupid law… where is the prohibition of stupid laws in the Constitution?

However, then something unexpected happens: the gallery erupts in laughter. What am I missing? What’s so funny about the Supremes wasting everyone’s time and failing to protect our rights by prioritizing non-issues like this case? Definitely not hilarious.

Changing the lyrics of “Stupid Hoe” to “Stupid Law” and imagining Nicki roasting Scalia, the Federalist Society, and everyone else using the courts to further injustice? Funny. However, YouTube didn’t have that (yet). So, please enjoy Arty tearing it up with ASL instead.

 

This is important, and time is running out.  Craft breweries are getting crushed during the pandemic.  Many are hanging on by a government PPP string.  The Denver Post recently reported that at least 170 independent craft breweries closed during the first half of 2020.  The number is likely to be much larger at present.  Most of these small businesses are in a bad way.  The government needs to get off its rear to help out.

In 2017, Congress provided a temporary reduction in federal excise taxes on beer through the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (specifically the Craft Beverage Modernization and Tax Reform Act (S. 362/H.R. 1175)).  What did these reductions mean?  It reduced the federal excise tax for breweries producing fewer than 2 million barrels annually from $7.50 to $3.50 per barrel for the first 60,000 barrels.  By the way, this grouping encompasses the vast majority of 8000+ independent craft breweries in the U.S.  It did some other stuff too, but those benefits were for gargantuan mega breweries and importers so not the focus here.  Especially during COVID and the serious decline in sales for independent breweries, this $4.00 savings per barrel is extremely important.

What’s the problem?  The Act is set to expire on December 31, 2020.  If Congress does not act, independent breweries (more than 2000 have opened since the Act went into effect) will see their taxes essentially double.  Really?  At a time like this?  Frankly, many independent breweries simply can’t take the hit and will have to close up shop.

It doesn’t matter if you don’t like beer.  I bet you like jobs.  According to the Brewers Association, craft beer provided 580,000 jobs in the US in 2019.  While that number has certainly shrunk since the 2019 stats came in.  We should all want to stop the bleeding of breweries and their half-million plus jobs.

And it’s not like it’s controversial.  The Beer Institute provides that the Act had largely bipartisan support in both the Senate and the House.  340 members of the House and nearly three quarters of the Senate to be specific.  We should push Congress to extend the Act to allow breweries to invest in their survival through COVID, to allow brewery employees to remain gainfully employed, and to allow us hangers on to drink their fine products.  If there has to be a fight about it, please, lawmakers, make it after the pandemic.  Now get to work.

Let your representatives know that you care about your local breweries and that you support extending the Craft Beverage Modernization and Tax Reform Act.  They’ll be too busy bickering, I’m sure.  But being heard is a start.

Cheers.  And let me know what you think.

 

Environmental Law is predicated on the assumption that the government can effectively motivate its citizens to perform or abstain from certain activities. The question is how incentives and punishments should be used to achieve and ensure the greatest effect. There is evidence to suggest that excessive reliance on the threat of punishment alone is not only insufficient but counterproductive. Furthermore, without having clear metrics, it is unreliable to use any mixture of deterrent or incentive. This is especially true for the transportation sector.
The US EPA and other state and local regulatory agencies do not have sufficient resources to thoroughly police all individuals and organizations to ensure total compliance. As a consequence, many individuals and organizations intentionally avoid compliance often through deceptive means. On the smallest level, it is not uncommon for individuals in California to cheat on smog tests as evidenced by internet forums discussing how to get around smog checks. On a larger scale, there was the major scandal with Volkswagen cheating US EPA regulations by programming their vehicles to detect drive cycles and adjust engine performance to produce a different emission pattern than regular driving. People ex rel. Madigan v. Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft. If it was not for independent research, this scandal may never have been exposed.
Why do these occur? In large part, it is because the regulatory and economic circumstances converged to incentivize individuals and organizations to take the risk of non-compliance. The risk of non-compliance appeared less likely than the reward. When government regulations produce perverse incentives they need to be restructured if they are going to be effective. Does that mean harsher penalties? Perhaps not. B.F. Skinner discovered with a variety of organisms that the threat of punishment is less effective than using various schedules of positive reinforcement. Further studies in management have revealed there are ideal ratios of positive reinforcement and criticism. There is further evidence of this with the adoption of electric vehicles due to government incentives.
Any approach should involve meticulously collecting and analyzing quantifiable data to demonstrate with a reasonable degree of statistical probability if a given regulation or incentive is actually achieving its intended effect. In many respects, the relative success of the Clean Air Act was the insistence on quantifiable data. Another aspect of the CAA was the tangibility of what they were trying to avoid. It is much easier to grasp why thick smoke is harmful to health than why invisible emissions are causing climate change. More so than other pollutants proposals to reduce greenhouse gas emissions must involve the development and adoption of technology. That necessarily means any Environmental Law must correctly produce the ratio of punishment to the incentive.
In the 1990s President Clinton initiated the Clean Car Program to spur green innovation within the automotive industry. This led to the EPA developing technology with the public sector in public partnerships through their Clean Automotive Technology program. Despite some of this technology being commercialized, the program was eventually terminated. The primary reason for this shutdown was because of greater regulatory power during the Obama administration. What was the point of using taxpayer dollars to help companies innovate when the government could just force them to increase fuel efficiency? I argue that kind of thinking is what lead to the disaster with VW. It also enabled the current administration to shut out valuable research for establishing fuel economy standards.
Automakers face enormous constraints from both the government and the market. Government threats are crippling, market threats are existential. The data indicates many of these regulations resulted in millions of vehicles are produced which are less popular. The total environmental effect of creating unused vehicles is arguably more catastrophic.
A better way to draft an effective policy is to approach the problem from a multi-disciplinary approach and have concrete metrics associated with each discipline. The problems that policy attempts to solve involve just as much complexity, if not more, than the vehicles that those policies are meant to regulate. Every vehicle is composed of thousands of parts from a long supply chain of plastics, metals, electronics, aerodynamics, material science, and more. An inaccurate model will lead to a vehicle that cannot drive or will quickly fall apart. Likewise, for the policy, there need to be network models that involve at minimum variables from disciplines of psychology, sociology, game theory, macroeconomics, supply-chain, and manufacturing. Yet, most of the policies that are introduced reflect a model of governance that still has not grappled with the vast potentials of data science and machine learning.
At present many policies appear to be drafted from a simplistic view of wanting to achieve a simple metric, say increase fuel-economy, through bureaucratic enforcement and incentives. A metric that ignores the greater environmental harm that may be occurring as a consequence of attainment or nonattainment. For the policy of the future to be effective it must be as sophisticated as the reality it hopes to regulate and as precise as the goal it seeks to achieve.
The startup world has demonstrated customer discovery is essential. Virtually any product is doomed to fail, no matter how innovative or sophisticated, without first talking to the end-user. A more sophisticated technical model combined with a willingness to actually speak with the people these policies aim to influence is where it all comes together.
Ultimately policy should be crafted using sophisticated models with tangible metrics that recognize the incentives across multiple domains through conversations with the people it aims to regulate and motivate. Without a robust balance of interpersonal communication and statistical analysis, we risk not only failing to achieve our goals but potentially making things worse.

This is a summary of the 5G conference that took place on February 28, 2020, at the USD school of law.

What is 5G?

5G is the next generation of wireless communication technology systems or “ecosystem.” It promises three improvements: (1) Speed (2) Bandwidth (3) Latency.

What is the difference between speed, bandwidth, and latency?

If you imagine the internet as a series of interconnected highways you can think of the connections in terms of roads. The bandwidth or density is akin to the number of lanes. It is the measurement of how many cars can fit on the highway or how much information can be transferred at once. The speed is how quickly a car can get from point A to point B. The latency is the measure of the delay for that car to make the round trip.Bandwith Speed Latency Image

These measures are dependent on each other, which is why it is a technology ecosystem. The speed of your machine or server receiving and sending signals will affect the overall latency. Likewise, the bandwidth of the connection will affect the latency.

In general, you want HIGH bandwidth, HIGH speed, and LOW latency. 5G promises to improve these by a factor of 10 to 100. For example with 4G,  you can download a two-hour movie in 40 minutes, whereas with 5G it will take less than 10 minutes.

Low latency is most critical for new applications. 4G has a latency of 50ms while 5G offers a lower latency of 1ms. With low latency, devices can more easily communicate with servers and each other. For example, an autonomous vehicle quickly processes a sensor input to avoid colliding with another vehicle. Thus, 5G will open up the application for the internet of things or IoT.

IoT Mesh networks?

Mesh Network Diagram

One of the biggest challenges of IoT is how devices communicate with one another. 5G reduces that latency to allow for more devices to transmit information more quickly and reliably. Furthermore, 5G allows devices to communicate directly with each other without requiring them to go through a server. This has huge implications for the future of autonomous vehicles in particular. If cars can instinctively communicate directly with other vehicles or smartphones many of the current challenges with autonomous vehicles could be solved. Emergency response systems could be greatly improved by decreasing delays from sensors to response teams. Drones could form mesh networks to give real-time information for emergency managers.

Wearable Device ImageFor your everyday consumer, a low latency highly reliable mesh network means the advent of augmented reality devices. At the moment,  a major hurdle of augmented devices is the data processing of input data from sensors. If the local device needs to compute that data it adds substantial physical weight in order to provide sufficient computing power. Whereas if the device is integrated into a wireless network all it needs to do is send data, receive the processed data, and display the results. Meaning you could wear a light pair of glasses equipped to record your surroundings and display real-time information.

5G Development and Deployment

Research, Standards then CommercialAs one might expect 5G technology is complicated. It should not come as a shock the legal dynamics are also complicated. Those legal issues were the focus of the recent 5G conference at USD. There are three broad stages to 5G coming to a device near you. Research, standardization, and commercialization. Various companies, many of whom were represented at the conference, are involved in the 5G research and development stage. As a consequence, billions of dollars are spent to develop technologies that can be patented.

Patents, FRAND, LicensingThese various companies who develop 5G technology come together to oversee standards in organizations, such as the International Telecommunications Union and the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers. The standards organizations set technical standards enabling the various technologies to work together. The standards are like a building code. From there the inventors and producers of devices can build the specific devices and physical tech. Converging Patents DiagramAs part of the standardization agreement, these companies who hold these patents agree to Fair Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory licensing agreements (FRANDs). In theory, this should make it easier for manufacturers to license from the patent holders. Unfortunately, that is rarely the case. Smaller manufacturers, in particular, have a significant disadvantage in determining who to license from and negotiating a reasonable rate that will actually be accepted by the market.

To make matters worse, oftentimes a single piece of technology is built on stacks of patents that are held by different companies. This extremely complicated bundle of patents with seemingly endless numbers of patents is referred to as the “patent thicket.”

If you’re a manufacturer there is an incentive to commit what is termed an “efficient breach.” Ever since Winter v. Natural Res. Def. Council, Inc., 129 S.Ct. 365, 172 L.Ed.2d 249, 555 U.S. 7 (2008) getting an injunction against infringement is much more difficult for patent holders. This allows some unscrupulous manufacturers to intentionally violate patents and just pay fees if they ever get caught. Some businesses rely on a business model in which their whole source of revenue comes from licensing. On the other hand, there are patent trolls who intentionally exploit manufacturers. A patent troll will often buy patents for the sole purpose of exploiting manufacturers who have unwittingly violated those patents.

One solution that has been proposed is patent pools. In that scenario, the various patent holders create a pool that allows manufacturers to come to one place, pay one licensing fee, and move on to commercialization. The problem with that is the competing interests of the patent holders. Many patent holders have spent billions of dollars in research and development and understandably want to recoup that investment. Thus original patent holders are inclined to demand a larger piece of the pie. Sometimes they want to secretly recoup all of their research and development costs, even if it was not directly useful or fruitful. Thus they put a bigger price tag on their patents than it may well deserve.

The other issue is how to determine if the licensing fee is correct. Should it be licensed at the unit level? If so should the different units be licensed differently? For example, should a chip on a drone cost more than on a cell phone? All of these licensing agreements are supposed to be made in advance of commercialization which means the manufacturer takes a gamble that the licensing fee, along with the other costs of manufacturing will be accepted by the market.

Supply Chain Diagram

Thus, a licensing fee sometimes reflects the demands of the companies who are trying to recoup their investments more so than what an end-user would actually be willing to pay.

The other problem is that because these are often merely pieces of a given device, the value of that piece can be overblown. The analogy frequently given is how much would you be willing to pay for a car with windshield wipers vs. one without wipers? Should that price difference be reflected in the licensing fee? Yet any given device is greater than the sum of its parts. If all the components in a vehicle are priced based on the amount consumers are willing to pay more for that component given the option of not having it, what emerges is a complete vehicle more expensive than any consumer would be willing to pay. In other words, the price of the components is determined by the price of the whole.

National Security Interests

The United States has accused one of the biggest developers of 5G, Huawei, of creating back doors in their 5G technology. Chinese companies have spent an astonishing amount of money in developing this technology and are racing to get it implemented. The US has effectively banned any use of the 5G tech in the united states over fears of espionage and interference.

In recent years China has increased its respect for intellectual property and has begun implementing a much more reliable enforcement mechanism. It is certainly conceivable that some of the patents necessary to the deployment of 5G are held by the Chinese who may be a lot less willing to cooperate. Furthermore, China is much more efficient with deployment because the government can force cooperation within their tech sphere. Thus, the complications described above become less thorny and as a result,  China will likely have 5G before we do. Thus, putting the US at a distinct disadvantage technologically and by extension, economically. Despite the credible evidence put forward by the US, Europe has still decided to move forward with implementing Huawei’s 5G technology. That means Europe may also have 5G before the US does. Nevertheless, many European companies like Eriksson and Nokia, who had representatives at the conference, are very interested in their 5G technology being used in the US and abroad.

Moving Forward

There are organizations that are dedicated to simplifying the licensing process. Unified Patents, for example, provides a patent search using artificial intelligence to identify potential patent holders that might be essential to proper licensing. They also bring suit against patent trolls and other companies that hold suspect patents that should be invalidated. Unsurprisingly, representatives from Unified Patents got into a rather heated exchange with some of the other companies represented at the conference.

The copyright system has effectively overcome an analogous problem with the use of mechanical royalties. While a one-size-fits-all fee will be unlikely to be profitable for the patent holders a similar process might be necessary to streamline the licensing process for innovators and manufacturers. Given the significance of this technology, bipartisan interest in the issue should overcome some of the intransigences in passing federal legislation to streamline these issues. Various agencies, such as the FCC, USPTO, FTC, and NSA have proven to be surprisingly cooperative with telecommunications issues. The law always lags behind technology, but perhaps a little legal creativity and innovation can reduce that latency. This is a field that any law student with an interest in IP and technology should pay very close attention to.

Many students approached this new school year with anxiety regarding technology. Four OU Law students, however, tackled technology head on – attending the jam-packed, completely virtual, International Legal Technology Association (ILTA)>ON technology conference.

 

OU’s College of Law generously sponsored four third-year students’ registration to the ILTA>ON conference. Cole Reynolds, Rich Lubbers, Amanda Finch, and Anthony Kanalas break down all their favorite moments from the conference in a recent TALIcast podcast, but some key takeaways are included here.

 

Conference Format

 

ILTA>ON was virtual conferencing done right. The programming offered a plethora of concurrent tracks and sessions with novel and varied content. It was challenging for the students to choose just one session to attend.

 

The conference was attended and presented by practitioners from all over the world. As a result, there were sessions offered much earlier and later than a typical in-person conference. This made it easier for, not only the international professionals, but also busy students to work in conference sessions at their convenience. Many presentations were also available on demand afterwards. So, to the extent that there was a conflict and you missed a presentation you were really interested in, you could watch it on your own time.

 

Amanda was particularly impressed with the conference’s integrative technology, such as interactive polls, that encouraged attendees to actively engage in the presentations in real time. She was also pleased with the ease of giving feedback as surveys were provided as a simple poll, on the screen, right at the end of each session. This format was not only convenient for attendees, but conference organizers were able to—and did—improve the experience continuously based on the quick feedback they received.

 

For many participants, networking is the primary goal of conferences. This is especially true for law students and other young professionals. Cole appreciated that ILTA>ON took this into consideration when they designed the “Hallway Chatter” sessions, which facilitated networking conversations, allowing attendees to catch up with and meet other conference goers outside of the moderated chat in the more formal sessions.

 

Favorite Sessions

 

If each of the students who attended could tell you one thing about this technology conference, in particular, it would be that it is about “more than gadgets and gizmos, the focus is really on the people, both those we serve and those we work with.” The ILTA>ON conference was not just about technology; it was about how technology supports and influences people.

 

This support, especially when it involves process changes, is often met with resistance. Rich noted that ILTA>ON addressed this difficulty through numerous sessions discussing tools and strategies to help get teams on board with technology improvements. He found the practical advice for how to leverage technology and implement change especially refreshing.

 

Amanda’s refreshment, however, was found in the sessions regarding emotional intelligence, as well as diversity and inclusion. She enjoyed being given concrete steps to affect change in your firm; and the emphasis on measuring change on a spectrum. Improving diversity and inclusion is more than just checking a box; it’s about collecting data and implementing evidence-based practices that rehabilitate the culture of a firm, while protecting, and many times, boosting the bottom dollar.

 

Anthony enjoyed learning about evidence-based practices surrounding the service perspective of embracing legal solutions. He came away realizing that while some professional environments could benefit from a complete technology overall, that approach is not always practical based on the resources available. It is crucial, therefore, to evaluate the metrics of the current systems to determine where efficiencies can best be realized through the implementation of new systems. This data-driven approach focuses on prioritizing upgrades, while convincing the whole team to come along for the ride.

 

As new technology is integrated into legal practice, these solutions impact real people and that reality should influence implementation decisions. This is why the leadership-oriented sessions appealed most to Cole. He was introduced to different ways to approach technology-based solutions to people problems. And, at the end of the day, or week even, this technology conference was about just that: people.

 

As a whole, the students appreciated how well OU Law’s Digital Initiative programming prepared them to fully engage in some of the more tech-heavy sessions. The ILTA>ON conference introduced skills and strategies that built on strong foundation of technical competency OU Law works hard to instill in its students. This investment will go far in assisting students as they transition into the legal profession.

 

Check out the latest TALIcast podcast episode to hear more!

 

Sydney N. Forsander, P.E., 3L

Secretary, Technology and Legal Innovation Society at the OU College of Law

“Mo Money Mo Problems:” How the Post-Mortem Right of Publicity Affects Craft Brewers

  1. Introduction

I once went to a taproom with an array of eighty self-serve beer taps. It was initially difficult to pick a beer from the eighty options. But soon, one caught my eye: North Coast Brewing Company’s “Brother Thelonious Belgian Style Abbey Ale.” The beer cleverly invoked the name of legendary jazz pianist Thelonious Monk and prominently featured him on the label with a snifter of ale. Being a fan of Thelonious Monk, picking a beer became an easy choice.

A Nielsen Holdings study affirms my taproom experience, finding sixty-six percent of American craft beer buyers believe a beer’s label—instead of reputation or price—is “extremely” important for grabbing their attention. In a crowded market with limited shelf space, a standout label is a great way to distinguish the beer and promote sales. And what better way is there to bring in customers than putting a famous person on the label? The practice is astonishingly common; for example, a quick web search presents dozens of The Notorious B.I.G. inspired beers (e.g. Notorious H.O.P, Notorious P.O.G., Notorious B.I.G., Hoppy Smalls, Big Poppa).

But a brewer using the name and likeness of a deceased celebrity presents right of publicity issues that outweigh the commercial benefits. The right of publicity is the “right of a person whose identity has commercial value . . . to control the commercial use of that identity.” See Waits v. Frito-Lay, Inc., 498 F.2d 1093, 1098 (9th Cir.1992). Celebrities have a property interest in their identities because their identities are “valuable in the promotion of products” and “unauthorized commercial exploitation” of their identities threatens their rights. White v. Samsung Electronics America, Inc., 971 F.2d 1395, 1398 (9th Cir. 1992). California has a common law version and a statutory version of the doctrine. The common law version does not survive death, but the statutory version applies post-mortem.

It is imperative that craft brewers understand the post-mortem right of publicity and tread lightly with deceased celebrity-based beer brands. When brewers ignore the right of publicity, they expose themselves to legal and financial costs associated with the misappropriation of a celebrity’s name and likeness. For example, North Coast Brewing Company recently had to settle for an undisclosed amount with Thelonious Monk, Jr. because it misappropriated the name and likeness of Thelonious Monk, Sr. on “Brother Thelonious” merchandise. Furthermore, if a brewer manages to defend their brand as a parody, other brewers are free to riff on the brand’s name and label. Guest Lecture with Mike Kanach, Intellectual Property Partner, Gordon, Rees, Scully & Mansukhani (June 27, 2020). As a result, other brewers can capture the initial market advantage of the celebrity-based beer. While there are technically ways to avoid harm when using a celebrity’s name and likeness, the best practice is to not have a dead celebrity-based beer because the financial risks are significant.

The Right of Publicity: California Civil Code § 3334.1 and The First Amendment

California Civil Code § 3334.1 provides that users of a deceased personality’s name or likeness for commercial purposes without prior consent are liable to the holder of the decedent’s right of publicity for damages resulting from that unconsented use. See Cal. Civ. Code § 3334.1. However, there are defenses under the First Amendment to the right of publicity. See Comedy III Productions, Inc. v. Gary Saderup, Inc. 25 Cal. 4th 387, 405–07 (2001).

  1. The Statutory Right of Publicity

California Civil Code § 3334.1 makes users of a “deceased personality[’s]” name or likeness on products, or in advertising or sales, liable for $750 or any damages the use causes—including lost profits—if they use the name or likeness without consent of the decedent’s estate. Cal. Civ. Code § 3334.1(a), (c). The injured party measures lost profits with the gross revenue attributable to the use of the personality. Cal. Civ. Code § 3334.1(a). The statute defines “deceased personality” as a person whose “name, voice, signature, photograph, or likeness has commercial value at the time of his or her death, or because of his or her death.” Cal. Civ. Code § 3334.1(h). The use of the decedent’s name or likeness must be “directly connected” to a commercial purpose. Cal. Civ. Code § 3334.1(k).

When a brewer uses a deceased personality on its beer’s label or brand name without consent from the decedent’s estate, it risks financial and legal costs from the misappropriation of the celebrity’s identity. For example, a brewer uses The Notorious B.I.G.’s name or likeness on it’s beer label or as the beer’s name without asking for permission from The Notorious B.I.G.’s estate which then sues the brewer under § 3334.1. These uses qualify as an unconsented use of Biggie’s personality that is directly connected to a commercial use because the name or likeness is on the product itself and promotes sale of the beer. The brewer would have to halt production and sales of the beer and may have to dump any remaining beer at the end of the lawsuit. Furthermore, a brewer using The Notorious B.I.G. on a beer’s label or brand name would cause his estate damages. The damages include gross revenue attributable to the use of The Notorious B.I.G.’s name or likeness and any noneconomic damages. The prevailing party receives attorney’s fees and costs, so if the brewer loses the case, it must pay these costs in addition to its own attorney’s fees. As a result, it is easy to see how a brewer could financially suffer through its unconsented use of a dead celebrity’s identity because lost profits, noneconomic damages, dumping the beer, attorney’s fees and costs add up to substantial sums of money. Most brewers in this scenario can only survive by settling the case, but even settlements can set brewers back considerably.

The Ninth Circuit has held that § 3334.1 only applies to people domiciled in California at the time of death. See Cairns v. Franklin Mint Co., 292 F.3d 1139, 1147, 1149 (9th Cir. 2002). In Cairns, an American mint produced coins with Princess Diana on them, and the Princess’s estate sued the mint under § 3334.1. Id. at 1144. The Court explained British law on the right of publicity applied instead of § 3334.1 because the right of publicity is a personal property right and California law makes personal property rights dependent on the law of the plaintiff’s domicile unless another law provides otherwise. Id. at 1149. Thus, Princess Diana’s estate could not recover damages because Great Britain—her domicile—did not recognize the post-mortem right. Id. at 1149. However, one court recently reframed the law, suggesting there is a claim under § 3334.1 if the decedent’s domicile at the time of death recognizes the post-mortem right of publicity. See Bravado Int’l Grp. Merchandising Servs. v. Gear Launch, Inc., 2018 WL 6017035, 9 (C.D. Cal. 2018).

Under Cairns, using a dead celebrity’s image is outside the scope of § 3334.1 if the celebrity’s domicile was not California when they died. Cairns, 292 F.3d at 1149. However, a celebrity’s estate may have a claim under the Bravadointerpretation of § 3334.1 if the celebrity’s domicile at the time of death offers a post-mortem right of publicity. See Bravado Int’l Grp. Merchandising Servs., 2018 WL 6017035 at 9. Continuing our Notorious B.I.G. example, New York law on the right of publicity would govern under Cairns, while § 3334.1 may apply under the more recent Bravado holding. Given the Bravado holding, a shift in the law is possible, so brewers must be careful when using a dead celebrity’s identity without consent even if they died domiciled outside of California. Otherwise, brewers expose themselves to liability and might divest themselves of their profits.

  1. The First Amendment Defense

Brewers may avoid financial ruin under a First Amendment defense after using a dead celebrity’s personality for a beer brand or label without consent. Because the statute does not exempt beer brands or labels, celebrity-based beers may only receive protection as a parody. To qualify as a parody, the beer brand or label must contain “significant transformative elements” beyond celebrity likeness or its “value . . . [must] not derive primarily from the celebrity’s fame.” See Comedy III Productions, Inc., 25 Cal. 4th at 407 (2001).

“Transformative elements” hinge on whether the work “adds something new, with a further purpose or different character, altering the first with new expression, meaning, or message.” Comedy III Productions, Inc., 25 Cal. 4th at 404. In Comedy III, an artist sketched The Three Stooges and sold merchandise bearing their image, causing the owner of their rights of publicity to sue for misappropriation of their identities. Id. at 407. The Court held that the work was not transformative because it literally resembled the Stooges rather than transforming their images into something more than celebrity likeness. Id. at 409. The Court explained that the focus is on whether the defendant transforms the celebrity’s likeness such that it becomes the defendant’s own creative expression. Id. at 406. Thus, the artist could not claim his work was transformative because he simply “[created] a conventional portrait of a celebrity so as to commercially exploit” the celebrity’s fame. Id. at 408. Conversely, in ETW Corp. v. Jireh Publishing, Inc., the Sixth Circuit held that a painting commemorating Tiger Woods’s victory at the Augusta Masters Tournament was transformative because the work did not simply depict Woods but combined other images “to describe, in artistic form, a historic event in sports history and convey a message about the significance of Woods’s achievement.” See ETW Corp. v. Jireh Publishing, Inc., 332 F.3d 915, 938 (6th Cir. 2003).

However, a court is unlikely to consider most celebrity-based beer brands and labels to be transformative because their names and artwork are not clearly making a commentary or critique. For example, one Biggie-inspired beer—simply called “Notorious B.I.G.”—provides no commentary and instead copies the rapper’s name. Another example is a beer called “Label Us Notorious”—a lyric from The Notorious B.I.G.—featuring a silhouette image of The Notorious B.I.G. behind a microphone. It is unclear if this beer qualifies as a parody because its artwork does not “transform” Biggie’s image beyond his likeness. Rather, it appears the brewery is simply pulling from the original source to benefit off of the celebrity’s likeness. Furthermore, the commentary provided is not readily apparent other than the brewer touting its notoriety. As a result, the beer brand likely commercially exploits The Notorious B.I.G.’s identity. However, if a brewer made a brand or label that is a distinct expression depicting more than The Notorious B.I.G.’s likeness and conveying a significant message, the brewer may prevail. In short, if a brewer is going to parody a celebrity without permission, they not only should expect a lawsuit, but also, they should be good at parodying in a transformative manner.

If a brewer successfully defends their beer as a parody, the brewer will avoid financial loss associated with the lawsuit because the losing party must cover the brewer’s costs. However, the brewer risks other losses because it is unclear if the brewer has intellectual property protections in the brand and label since the beer brand is a riff on existing intellectual property. (Guest Lecture with Mike Kanach.) In theory, a brewer should receive protection since it made a sufficiently expressive and new mark, but protections remain uncertain which allows others to copy the parody. (Guest Lecture with Mike Kanach.)

III. How Craft Brewers Can Avoid Issues with the Right of Publicity

Craft brewers can avoid liability from the right of publicity if they sufficiently parody the celebrity. However, parody does not avoid the issue but invites it. Instead of leaning on parody, brewers often blatantly appropriate the name and likeness of celebrities in “one-off runs” and sell small batches of beer from their taprooms over a short period of time. Typically, the beer is gone and the sale is over before the brewer receives a cease and desist letter. Serving small amounts of beer exclusively in the taproom allows brewers to market it as a limited-edition offer. Additionally, serving beers from the taproom often involves no artwork invoking the likeness of the celebrity, and if it does it can simply be a parody or rework. Furthermore, the profits generated in these one-offs are miniscule in comparison to continuous sales, which reduces the incentive of filing a lawsuit because the gross revenue does not outweigh the costs of a lawsuit. In that sense, it really is “Mo Money Mo Problems.”

Even so, one-off runs are not advisable because stealing other’s intellectual property is financially and legally risky and ethically questionable. Brewers should not make this behavior a regular practice because continuous appropriation of other’s property makes right of publicity holders and courts less likely to be forgiving in future litigation. Rather, if a brewer seeks to use the name and likeness of a dead celebrity, it would be prudent for the brewer to reach out to the holder of the celebrity’s right of publicity and enter into a licensing agreement to avoid future lawsuits. Still, an agreement does not guarantee zero right of publicity issues; for example, North Coast had an agreement with Thelonious Monk, Jr. before their lawsuit regarding “Brother Thelonious Abbey Ale.” Instead, the best way to avoid issues is to simply not appropriate the name and likeness of a dead celebrity at all. By not using a deceased personality, brewers entirely avoid any potential issues associated with the post-mortem right of publicity.

  1. Conclusion

Right of publicity challenges outweigh the commercial benefits of using a deceased personality in beer brands and labels. If brewers ignore the post-mortem right of publicity, they risk financial harm because the statutory right of publicity prevents future sales and redeems lost profits, noneconomic damages, attorney’s fees, and costs. There are ways to avoid this fallout through parody, but just because a brewer can defend a brand in a lawsuit does not mean it should because parody allows other brewers to riff on the brand, diluting the commercial advantage of the initial parodist. Furthermore, brewers may limit production and sell the celebrity-based beers only in their taproom as a one-off run to disincentivize a lawsuit because a one-off small batch sale limits the profits that the estate could recover. However, this behavior still exposes craft brewers to legal challenges from often well-financed owners of a post-mortem right of publicity. Brewers can avoid issues from the unconsented use of a deceased personality by contacting the holder of the right of publicity and making a written licensing agreement to use the name and likeness of the celebrity on the beer and associated merchandise. But this can sometimes devolve into legal battles that can also harm brewers and divest them of profits. Thus, the best way to avoid issues is by simply not having a dead celebrity-based beer brand at all.