Today we’ll take a look at what Ray LeBov and I consider the key elements of successful lobbying in California. The first of these four is the Four P’s.

The Four P’s are: Process, players, policy, and personality.

  • Process – Understand the rules governing the legislative process in the Constitution, the Government Code, the Joint Rules, and the Assembly and Senate rules, not just the rules of how a bill becomes law, but all the rules, whether they cover ethics or the details of the budget process.
  • Players – Who are the players on both sides of the issue or the bill that you’re working on? Both the public officials, the elected officials, the staff, the administration officials, and the private sector, proponents and opponents, have a working relationship with all of them.
  • Policy – know your bill and have a working knowledge of the subject matter in general.
  • Personality – Exhibit a pleasant demeanor when working with others during the legislative process. We’re all professionals, and you can just as easily find yourself working on the same side of an issue as you can working against somebody. So treat others with respect and expect the same treatment for yourself.

Beyond the Four P’s, what are the three other keys to effective lobbying?

  • Seek guidance from others – talk to your colleagues and staff and others to learn more about a bill, a public policy area, or the legislative process itself. And listen to suggestions that are made by others with whom you work. Ask others why they succeeded or why they failed with a particular bill or issue.
  • Keep your word – Your reputation as a lobbyist can be made or broken by what you do, how you do it, and what you say.
  • Be flexible – one’s best-laid plans sometimes run into unforeseen hurdles that you have to get over. It’s important to be flexible in your dealings with others throughout the legislative process.
  • Do your research – Whether it’s for your bill, a public policy issue, or even a legislator that you’re about to lobby, it’s important to do at least some basic research

You can find the transcript of the audio in today’s post here.

In 2021, the peak of the coronavirus, the McGeorge Unity Caucus (UC) saw a gap in much needed resources. Specifically, our students were not receiving the same opportunities to network as they had been when we could be in person. Additionally, in reviewing the yearly goals, one such gap was the lack of education on how to review the diversity initiatives of employers. In the legal field it is currently trendy to claim diversity and diversity initiatives, but some such claims do not hold as much weight as others. After brainstorming methods to address this issue, the idea of a resume collect and mixer was discussed. It would be paired with a discussion going over methods students can use to check firms’ websites for their diversity initiatives and helpful questions to ask employers to determine their actual dedication to diversity issues.

The obvious issue was that we could not plan an in-person event and, during the pandemic, our students would benefit more from being able to practice virtual skills as well. McGeorge had worked with the Student Bar Association to purchase access to a novel platform, Remo, that allowed students and employers to sit at virtual “tables” together. Participants could also switch tables to engage with other employers and practice the skills discussed during the event. The Unity Caucus formed a committee made up of Ashley Silva-Guzman (’21), Sofia Schersei (’22), and Julienne Correa (’22). Ashley, Sofia, and Julienne contacted Dean Molly Stafford at the Career Development Office. She had already been contemplating this need and the work began.

It was well organized, smooth, and as an employer, it was fantastic to talk with students from such a diverse pool – both academically and professionally.  We have hired several McGeorge graduates (and I am one such proud member) and we will continue to do so.”

Sue Ann Van Dermyden, Shareholder. Van Dermyden Makus Law Corp.

The Career Development Office had already reached out to employers with trusted diversity initiatives and had previously provided opportunities to diverse law clerks. The UC committee worked on the student side, drumming up interest by creating posters and managing the day-of plans. In the end, fourteen employers signed up to attend or collect resumes and forty-two students RSVP’d and submitted their resumes. The committee sent out details for the event and instructions on how to use the Remo platform. Dean Stafford gave a stirring introduction reviewing and embracing the importance of diversity initiatives at firms and encouraging students to rotate tables. Students spent a successful hour and a half mingling with employers and discussing their resumes with recruiters and attorneys that could assist them in reviewing the diversity initiatives at their unique firms. The opportunities that are built at firms that value and embrace diverse law clerks are so much more successful when firms devote themselves to these initiatives.

The Diversity Mixer and Resume Collect Event allowed for employers and applicants to meet and share information when in the past, employers would typically be limited to interviewing applicants in the immediate area. I walked away with a sense of appreciation of the quality of the interactions and the number of applicants that we were able to meet.”

John Chang, Deputy District Attorney. Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office

 

About the event co-founders

Ashley Silva-Guzman graduated in May of 2021. After sitting for the July 2021 Bar she began working as a Law Clerk at the Corporate Immigration Partners out of San Francisco.

Julienne Alexis Correa is a 3L at McGeorge School of Law. She currently works at the Sacramento County Office of the Public Defender as a Legal Research Assistant.

Sofia Schersei is a 3L at McGeorge School of Law. She is the Editor-in-Chief of Pacific Law Review and has accepted an offer to join Van Dermyden Makus Law after graduating.

I recently took a look at how the number of bills that Governor Newsom signed and vetoed compared to previous years in his administration and previous governors. Today let’s look at some themes that emerged for why he vetoed the bills that he did.

The most common reason – which is not unique to Governor Newsom – was fiscal cost, which appeared in different forms. One was that the budget process should have been used for bills resulting in costs to the state. Another variation was expressing concern that the measure would create permanent impacts on the state’s general fund.

Some non-fiscal themes that Governor Newsom expressed throughout his vetoes were:

  • Would prefer state agencies work with the Legislature on a solution.
  • The bill would create confusion with existing state or federal law.
  • A state agency was/is already addressing the issue with regulations.
  • The bill would interfere with the work of an existing state agency.
  • The bill would conflict with federal law.
  • Adverse impacts on the private sector.
  • Wants further study or refinement before the particular bill should become law.
  • Vetoing a bill that he had previously vetoed.
  • The bill interferes with the collective bargaining process.

You can find the transcript of the audio in today’s post here.

Are you searching for resources to help grow your legal expertise, but don’t know where to start? Is law school harder and more stressful than you imagined it would be? Don’t worry, because help is here!

As an ABA law student, you are eligible for a free membership to ABA For Law Students. Gain access to exclusive job boards, bar prep discounts, networking opportunities, and much more. Check out the link above and start taking advantage of your membership!

According to a report on Asians in America released by Pew Research Center this April, about 14% of unauthorized immigrants in the United States in 2017 were of Asian descent. The number highlights the fact that Asians in America are not a monolith—we are a diverse group coming from diverse backgrounds with diverse needs.

In recent years, as anti-immigrant sentiment has increased, Asian communities have experienced the effects firsthand. For example, in Northern California, in the past few years alone, deportations of Cambodian Americans have gone up 279%.

Immigrants rights groups like Asian American Advancing Justice-Asian Law Caucus and NorCal Resist, along with lawmakers, have fought to stop the deportations of hundreds in the Southeast Asian refugee community. Many Asian immigrants have found themselves in ICE custody and deportation proceedings through transfers from their local prison after completing their sentence. This included Phi Pham, a Vietnamese refugee and formerly incarcerated firefighter, who was featured on the cover of the San Francisco Chronicle.

In response, the VISION Act was created to stop ICE transfers. Co-sponsored by 50 organizations, including the Asian Law Caucus, the VISION Act was priority legislation for the API, Latinx, and Black Legislative Caucuses. The VISION Act has currently been put on hold, but advocates continue to fight against such transfers.

If you or someone you know is an unauthorized immigrant living in the United States, you can find more information on your rights and how to speak with ICE in the Immigrant Defense Project links below. All people in the United States, regardless of immigration status, have certain rights and protections under the U.S. Constitution. And to report ICE activity, you can call the Sacramento FUEL Network’s Rapid Response Hotline at 916-245-6773.

About Kishwer Vikaas

Kishwer is a Staff Attorney at University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law’s Immigration Clinic. She has been an attorney in the Immigration Clinic since July 2017.

As 1Ls prepare application materials in a bid to participate in the 2022 SCBA Diversity Fellowship, John Gutierrez (’23) shared his experience as a fellow in last year’s program and what it has done for his law school journey. Read John’s story below:

John Gutierrez, ’23

“I have always loved storytelling. As a child, my mother would lull me to bed with old Mexican-heritage stories from her abuelita that painted reminiscent pictures of Jalisco’s red-dirt ranches that we would visit in the hot summers. Although I did not know it at the time, these stories were my first cultural connection to my Mexican heritage. Their folkloric lessons introduced me to my family values and, in time, taught me to love my Chicano identity that seemed ever fleeting as my family assimilated into an American lifestyle.

Yet, after my first year in law school, storytelling seemed out of place in the legal profession amidst rote memorization of statutes and regulations. However, my participation in the Sacramento County Bar Associations’ (SCBA) Diversity Fellowship in my 1L summer showed me the part of the law that I was missing: the law is a tool for telling stories.

The SCBA Diversity Fellowship placed me with Boutin Jones Inc., Attorneys at Law, in Sacramento, California. Boutin Jones is Sacramento’s premier business law firm and the firm aspires to a client-centered approach. A critical part of client-centeredness is learning your client’s story and communicating that story to the court.

Whether I was helping a client amend a trust to protect their family’s earnings, or helping a business collect on a judgment that they fairly deserved, every assignment involved telling a story. It was my responsibility to learn the history of the case, actively read the facts, perform legal research with purpose, and apply the law in creative ways to achieve our client’s desired outcome. Through this process, I helped create seamless stories that my firm used to advocate for our clients. Indeed, storytelling is a critical component of the legal profession.

The SCBA Diversity Fellowship is one of those rare gems that can make a transformational change in a person’s life.  Before my 1L summer, I had zero experience in private law and had few connections in the legal field.  Yet, my Fellowship gave me the chance to work hard and demonstrate my legal skills in a top law firm filled with intelligent attorneys.  Without the SCBA Fellowship, I would never have had that chance.

Reapplying to Boutin Jones through McGeorge’s ‘On-Campus Interviews’ (OCI) was a no-brainer, and I was excited to speak about the skills I developed in my Fellowship.  My experience with billable hours, drafting client letters, and working independently gave me an edge over my peers.  I felt confident and prepared for all of my OCI applications because I knew my professional record in a leading firm made me a competitive applicant. Although I was fortunate to receive other OCI offers, I knew if I returned to Boutin Jones then I could learn and develop my legal skills in an environment where I felt welcomed and valued.  I am thrilled to have accepted a return offer from Boutin Jones for my 2L summer and I look forward to the challenging work ahead.

I am grateful that the SCBA Fellowship gave me what all law students desire the most: a chance. A chance to prove myself in a premier law office. A chance to learn from the best attorneys in Sacramento.  And a chance to learn that the legal profession is all about telling stories.”

With all the legislative deadlines completed, and all the bills signed or vetoed, we can now take a look at the 2021 legislative session by the numbers. Just more than 800 bills reached the Governor’s desk, including close to 700 bills that were passed in the final month of the legislative session.

2,421 bills were introduced in 2021. 828 bills were introduced in the State Senate, 1,593 came from the Assembly. In total, 836 bills made it to the desk of Governor Gavin Newsom, roughly 34.5% of the total number of bills introduced. 32% of the bills introduced were signed into law, and 3% of all bills introduced were vetoed.

Governor Newsom signed 770 of the 836 bills that reached his desk, good for a 92.1% signature rate. 66 bills were vetoed, meaning 7.9% of the bills reaching the governor’s desk got vetoed.

Of the 770 bills that were signed into law, 66% were Assembly Bills, 34% were Senate Bills. Of the Assembly Bills that were signed into law, 75% were authored by Democrats, 11.5% were authored by Republicans, and the remaining 13.5% were either committee bills or authored by the independent legislator. 76% of the Senate Bills that became law were authored by Democrats, 8.5% were authored by Republicans, and 15.5% were committee bills.

Of the 66 vetoed bills, 68% were AB’s and 32% were SB’s. Of the AB’s that were vetoed, 91% were written by Democrats, 4% by Republicans, and the remaining 5% came from committees or the independent legislator. As far as SB’s are concerned, 86% were authored by Democrats and 14% were written by Republicans.

Governor Newsom’s 7.9% veto rate this year is down from the 13% of bills he vetoed last year, when the length of the legislative session and the number of bills was cut down by the COVID-19 pandemic. Both are lower rates than the 16.5% of bills he vetoed in his first year.

By comparison, Governor Brown in his second stint as Governor received between 850 and 1,250 bills annually. He vetoed a low of 10% and a high of 15% of those bills. His predecessor, Governor Schwarzenegger received between 900 and 1.250 in his seven years as governor. He vetoed between 22% and 35%. In Governor Gray Davis’s five years, he received between 950 and 1,450 bills, vetoing a low of 6% and a high of 25% of the bills. Before him, Governor Pete Wilson received between 1,050 and 1,700 bills and vetoed between 8% and 24% of bills.

You can read a transcript of the audio in this post here.

Another topic that Ray LeBov and I have put thought into is advice for organizations hiring a lobbyist. There are numerous things to think about when you’re hiring an employee lobbyist or a contract lobbyist, and we offer some of our best practice suggestions for navigating that process.

Regardless of the type of individual an organization has to hire, either one internally as an employee or one externally as a contractor, the fundamental questions to ask yourself are still, what do I and my organization need and what does our lobbying effort need? Keep in mind that the individual(s) that you hire, whether they are an employee or a contractor, will be a public face for your company, your association, your industry, or your trade group. Choose wisely.

The first question to consider is whether to hire an employee lobbyist or a contract lobbyist. While a contract lobbyist can address some short-term needs, hiring for an in house lobbyist should have a long term view in mind. For employee, or in house, lobbyists, some other questions you should answer are do you want a newly minted individual or someone with more experience? Do you need to diversify your workforce? If so, remember to consider things like party affiliation, ethnicity, technical expertise, and relationships with elected or appointed officials.

For contract lobbyists, there are different questions you should look answer. Those include What expertise does the lobbyist bring to the table? Does their skill set match with your organization’s needs? What is their track record? Do they have any conflicts of interest that cannot be easily resolved?

You can find the transcript of the audio in today’s post here.

The CDO is excited to announce a new way to schedule your career advising appointments via Squarespace Scheduling! No more playing phone tag or back-and-forth emails needed to set up your next appointment – just pick a date and time and you’re set! Whatever your needs may be, we’ve got you covered. (Note: This will replace the scheduling feature on McGeorgeCareersOnline.)

Click the button at the top of the sidebar to schedule a meeting with a career advisor now or scan the QR code below to make an appointment from your phone!

 

CDO Scheduling QR code

You will be prompted to download the Scheduling app upon first scanning.

One of the most critical things for a lobbyist to get right is the lobbyist-client relationship. This is something my colleague Ray LeBov and I have written about before and the most important advice we can impart is that expectations need to be set early by both parties – what does the client expect from the lobbyist? What does the client need or want?

Sometimes those questions are easy and clear. Pass or defeat a specific bill, for example. However, there are other times where it may be less clear. In other instances, maybe they want to increase their presence or develop certain relationships. At a minimum, the client expects to be treated with respect, to be kept apprised of all major developments and to not have a lobbyist who has a conflict in representing the client.

There are a number of obligations to the client that can be found in the Institute of Governmental Advocates Code of Conduct. First, the lobbyist has definite ethical obligations to a client to be truthful, to follow the law, to protect any confidential and proprietary information that the lobbyist obtains. Second, the lobbyist should be an effective representative for the client. She or he must have knowledge and confidence throughout the legislative process when representing his or her client.

The lobbyist’s goal should be to under-promise and over-deliver, as Ray likes to say. Do not set unreasonable expectations or suggest the ability to achieve something that cannot realistically in fact be achieved. That does not bode well for a successful engagement between the lobbyist and her or his client. And when it comes to major decisions, remember that the client is the ultimate boss. It’s their money and interests at stake.

Some clients are located in, or frequently visit, Sacramento and may want to be much more involved in the lobbying effort whereas others never come to Sacramento, and some the lobbyist may never even meet face to face. Regardless of the location or the level of involvement of your client, the lobbyist needs to educate the client about the legislative process, about the personalities, about the policy and the politics, and of course, what the client should expect throughout the legislative process. The more the client understands what is happening under the Capitol dome, it’ll be better for both parties to this engagement.

You can find the transcript audio in this post here.