Over the years, my colleague, Ray LeBov, and I have seen some mistakes that are common among new lobbyists but have also been made by more experienced advocates as well. I’ll detail some of those here.

Not reading the bill

Don’t rely on someone else’s description or understanding of the bill. Read the bill and any committee or floor analyses of the bill.

 

Not having paper 

Always provide a leave behind. Whether you deliver a physical piece of paper, by hand, or send it in an email, leaving a one-pager (or two if the bill is particularly complicated or detailed) helps jog the memory of the people you’ve lobbied. And they’ll have something written that they can reference after your conversation with them.

 

Taking votes for granted

Even if you think a legislator is likely to vote with your position, take the time to pay a courtesy visit. Don’t rely on only a hunch. Even if you think the legislator will vote against your position, check. Sometimes you might be pleasantly surprised that the legislator might actually vote with your stated position.

 

Failing to meet with both committee consultants

Both the majority party and the minority party have committee consultants. Be sure to communicate with both of them and supply them with the same paperwork so that all elected officials have the same information and these consultants have all the relevant details to complete their bill analyses.

 

Not finding the right bill author

This merits its own article but note that this takes time and effort to determine the best author for your bill. There are myriad factors that go into selecting the best bill author,

 

Not reading the room

Whether you’re in a legislator’s office or in a committee hearing; whether you’re for or against a bill, read the room. My colleagues and I can’t count how many times we’ve seen other lobbyists at the podium or at the table read their entire testimony for several minutes, right after the committee just admonished them to keep it brief.

 

Not understanding/appreciating the lobbyist/client relationship

Manage your client’s expectations. You need to establish how questions like “How is information provided?” “Who determines strategy and tactics?” and more are addressed before you get going in your relationship with your client.

 

Not telling the whole story

Eventually, everything becomes public in the legislative process. It is better to let everyone know in advance about a development, particularly an adverse one, than for them to find out about it from someone else.

 

Not being careful with what gets put in writing

In today’s world with social media and easily forwardable emails word travels fast. If you don’t want something widely known, don’t put it in writing.

You can find the transcript of the audio in this post here.

Today we’ll take a look at some key differences in four common legislative floor operations at the end of the legislative session versus earlier in the session.

Concurrence

Under Assembly Rule 77, a vote to concur in any Senate amendments to an Assembly Bill must meet the same vote threshold required for the bill itself to pass. This is generally a simple majority vote unless otherwise specified. However, the concurrence vote cannot be taken until the bill has been on the unfinished business file for one calendar day; this is known as the one-day waiting period. This does not apply to the last two days of the legislative session. Assembly Rule 77 can and does get suspended, as recently as the end of the 2020 legislative session.

The California Senate has no one-day waiting period. Senate Rule 29 still requires that the amended measure being returned to Senate from the Assembly with amendments appear in the unfinished business file of the Senate Daily File, and that Senators be provided with analysis of the amended Senate Bill, but there is no requirement in the Senate’s rules for one day to pass.

Floor Amendments

The two houses of the California Legislature operate slightly differently in how they amend the other house’s bills on the floor. In the Assembly, they are required to submit amendments the night before the Friday deadline, i.e. Thursday evening at 5:00 PM, although at the end of the session, the desk is known to stay open later to process the crush of amendments coming in. On Friday, the Floor Manager, that is the Assembly Member who is managing or presenting the Senate Bill on the Assembly floor, has to stand up on the floor and present the proposed amendments and seek approval for those amendments. Approval can either be made with the unanimous consent of the members or by a roll call vote. Any member can request a roll call vote. And in that case, the bill is amended by a majority of those present and voting.

In the Senate, amendments are not presented on the floor. Instead, amended bills are placed on the second reading file and amendments are processed by the Senate Desk. This effectively meant that, during the end of the 2021 session, amendments to ABs were made through 5 pm on the Friday before the last week of session.

Batching and the Consent Calendar

In recent years, the term “batching” has come up increasingly on the Assembly floor. It’s a process that once unanimous consent is received on the floor, permits a single vote for multiple bills or amendments to be adopted. It’s used, occasionally, when both the Democratic and Republican caucuses both have a support recommendation and no Republican legislators have abstained or voted no on the bill in committee or on the floor. It is most similar to the Senate’s special consent calendar.

Going Past Midnight

This question always arises at the end of session, as the clock ticks closer and closer to midnight, can legislative business be conducted after midnight on the last day of session?

In an even-numbered year, an election year, this question is clearly answered by California’s Constitution. Article IV, Section 10, Subdivision C states the Legislature must conduct work by midnight, August 31. There are three types of bills that are exceptions to this mandate.

However, in odd-numbered years, the date of adjournment is set by the Joint Rules of the Assembly and Senate. In past years, in following with its custom and practice, the Senate will work past the midnight deadline without suspending the Joint Rule. The Assembly, however, generally passes a resolution suspending the Joint Rule. Do they need to do that? I don’t think so. As a general principle of California’s separation of power doctrine, the judicial branch won’t consider a legal challenge to a statute that is alleged to have violated internal rule of procedure of either of the houses of the Legislature

You can find the transcript of the audio in today’s post here.

People often ask me what is the biggest problem that craft breweries face today.  To call a particular issue the “biggest” is nearly impossible considering the many ailments the craft brewing industry faces at present.  But there is one issue that stands out to me based on my experience with this industry as one that needs to change and is not supported by good policy:  legislative protections for distributors imbedded in distribution contracts.

Imagine you lovingly and successfully built a craft beer brand.  Your brand grew and grew until self-distribution wasn’t really an option anymore because you really never wanted to be a trucking company (complete with dispatch and car crashes and insane insurance).  You’d be proud, and if you were lucky, you’d attract the interest of a distributor who wants to take those trucking responsibilities away from you (for roughly 30% off the top).  Next imagine that two years have passed.  The distributor that you signed with sold your distribution rights to another distributor who you never wanted to do business with.  Worse yet, the new distributor has decided that it just doesn’t want to deliver your beer to the accounts that you cultivated over the years or that your brand has “plateaued” and is therefore not worthy of attention or promotion.  What can you do?  Answer in most states:  Nothing.

Most states provide statutorily mandated protections for distributors that make contracts between breweries and distributors heavily weighted in favor of distributors.  For example, most states provide distributors with transfer protections meaning that the distributor can sell a brewery’s distribution rights to another distributor with little or no say from the brewery.  In addition, most states provide termination protections whereby a brewery can only terminate a contract for statutorily defined “good cause” (something along the lines of fraud, bankruptcy, or other illegal conduct). California, for example, expressly states that a distributor’s failure to meet sales goals is not grounds for termination.  See Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 25000.7.  Further, distributors enjoy territorial exclusivity in most states.

What this boils down to is that distributors have breweries over a barrel.  They can buy and sell breweries’ distribution rights on whim; they can decide they don’t want to push a brand anymore for whatever reason; and because of territorial exclusivity, the brewery can’t find alternative means to get its product to shelves and tap handles.  Does that seem fair to you?

It is not.

The distributor’s lobby is powerful.  At the time many of these laws were passed, there were very few breweries and many small distributors.  So arguably, the small distributors were at the mercy of the few large breweries and were allegedly treated unfairly.  So distributors helped pass these laws to protect them from the whims of the few breweries.  The situation is precisely flipped today.

There are roughly 8500 breweries in the US, and the distribution tier is becoming more and more consolidated by the day.  I am saying that there is no legal or policy justification for providing distributors with legislative protections.  Not anymore (if there ever was).  Distributors have the power in the market without these legislative freebies.  They control whose beer goes where and how much.  Breweries have to sit by and hope.

This needs to change yesterday. I have seen too many breweries in this position—where they are stuck in an unhappy marriage with an indifferent distributor.  The brewery has to sit by and watch its brand die in those circumstances.  It’s not right.

I am starting a new project focused on this very important issue.   Stay tuned–I might need your help.

Post Script:  Some distributors are amazing and do incredible work.

With the 2021 legislative session at a close, we can now turn our attention to the actions Governor Newsom can take on the bills that were passed at the conclusion of the session on September 10. Governor Newsom can consider bills under October 10.

As a quick reminder, there are three actions that the governor can take on legislation on his or her desk. The governor can sign the bill into law. They can veto the bill. Or they can allow the bill to become law without a signature, California’s so-called pocket signature rule.

In this third year of Governor Newsom’s term, he received just over 800 bills to act on. That number was slightly depressed by the coronavirus pandemic compared to his first year in office. So far, he has acted on 159 of the 800 bills. During his first year in office, just over 1,000 bills were sent to Governor Newsom’s desk and he vetoed 16.5% of them. In his second year, where the pandemic reduced the number of bills introduced by 76%, just over 425 bills reached the governor’s desk. Newsom vetoed 13% of those bills.

How does this compare historically to other governors in the era of bill introduction limits? Since the 1990’s, when bill introduction limits were introduced, a typical year would have between 850 and 2,100 bills reach the Governor’s desk. Governor Pete Wilson usually received between 1,050 and 1,700 bills. His lowest veto rate was 8%, and his highest veto rate was 24%. In Governor Davis’s five years in office, he received between 950 and 1,450 bills and vetoed between 6% and 25%. Governor Schwarzenegger received between 900 and 1,250 bills during his term. He vetoed between 22% and 35% of bills. And most recently Governor Brown, in his second stint as governor, received between 850 and 1,200 bills annually, vetoing between 10 to 15% of them.

You can find the transcript of the audio in today’s post here.

First-generation law students often find themselves facing unique challenges and difficulties that many of their peers do not. From the general environment and structure of law school, to financial matters, networking, and even simply feeling like you belong with your cohort, it can be extremely taxing to try facing these issues by yourself. However, first-generation law students at McGeorge are in good company because you are not alone!

A significant portion of each incoming class at McGeorge are either first-generation college students or first-generation law students who can empathize with and support one another, in addition to receiving the support of faculty and staff. You can share experiences and insights with your fellow first-generation students and take advantage of McGeorge’s resources, like the CDO, Alumni Network and Alumni Mentors, the Center for Inclusion and Diversity, and many student organizations. If you are a first-generation law student, be sure to check out these tips for overcoming the unique challenges you may face.

We are all in this together, and no one needs to make the journey alone.

There are multiple players who take part in setting education policy in the state of California.

Article IX, which focuses on education, of the California Constitution has sixteen sections. Section 2 provides that a Superintendent of Public Instruction, sometimes referred to as SPI, shall be elected by the qualified electors of the state at each gubernatorial election. And no Superintendent of Public Instruction may serve more than two terms. The SPI is a nonpartisan office, although it’s worth noting that it was originally partisan.

The SPI directs all the functions of the Department of Education, and the SPI executes the policy set forth by the Department or the Board of Education, and the SPI chairs the Board of Education. Generally, they viewed as the state’s chief spokesperson for the public schools who provides education policy and direction to the local school districts. And he or she serves as an ex-officio member of the CSU community college and UC higher education systems.

Next is the State Board of Education, SBE, which was established in 1852. SBE is the governing and policy-making body of the California Department of Education. The board itself is comprised of 11 members, and note that both the Constitution and state statutes assign the State Board of Education a variety of different responsibilities.

The SBE has also adopted statewide academic standards for content and student performance in all the major topics: English, language arts, history, social science, math, science, visual and performing arts, and even physical education. Now 10 of the board’s 11 members are appointed by the governor for staggered four-year terms. They’re subject to confirmation by the state Senate, but not by majority vote. Instead, by a two-thirds vote, and that has to occur within one year of their appointment to the board.

The 11th member is also appointed by the governor and subject to Senate confirmation. However, that individual serves a one-year term and is a California public high school student. Note that the student does enjoy full voting rights and all the rights and privileges of the board membership. The only difference, again, is he or she serves a one-year term.

Then there is the Department of Education, CDE. CDE is under the direction of the Superintendent and the CDE implements the policies that have been adopted by the State Board of Education.

The Constitution also spells out the role that Legislature has in education policy in California as well.

You can find the transcript of the audio in today’s post here.

California, like all other states and the federal government, have a system for the employment of individuals, our public employee system. Many of the provisions for California’s public employee system are spelled out in our state’s constitution.

Article VII was added to the California Constitution by Proposition 14 on the June 8, 1976, ballot. It contains eleven sections.

  • Section 1 – Civil Service includes every officer and employee of the state except for those provided for elsewhere in the Constitution. Permanent appointment and promotion in civil service must be made under a general system based on merit by use of competitive examinations.
  • Section 2 – establishes the State Personnel Board
  • Section 3 – requires the State Personnel Board to enforce civil services statutes, and gives the Board other duties
  • Section 4 – Exempts from civil service individuals who are employed or appointed by the Legislature; employed by council or commissions in the judicial branch; elected by the people of California; members of Boards and Commissions; selected by Boards and Commissions or appointed by the Governor; state officers appointed by the Governor; employees of the Governor’s or Lieutenant Governor’s office; and many others.
  • Section 5 – Temporary civil service appoints may be made to a position where there is not an employment list, but no person may serve in such a role for more than nine months in a twelve consecutive month period.
  • Section 6 – The Legislature may provide preferences for veterans and surviving spouses of veterans
  • Section 7 – Prohibits a person holding a lucrative office under the United States or another power from holding a civil office
  • Section 8 – Every person who has been convicted of having given or offered a bribe to procure personal election or appointment is prohibited from holding any office of profit in California.
  • Section 9 – any person or organization that advocates for the overthrow of the government of the US by force or other illegal means, or who advocates support of a foreign government against the United States can’t hold office or employment.
  • Section 10 – No person who is found liable in a civil action for making libelous or slanderous statements against an opposing candidate at the state or local level can retain the seat to which they’ve been elected if the libel or slander was a major contributing cause in the defeat of an opposing candidate.
  • Section 11 – Prohibits the Legislature’s retirement system from paying any retirement allowance to any person who entered office after January 1, 1987.

You can find the transcript of the audio in today’s post here.

Since the closing of the courts in Hawaii on March 17, 2020 due to the novel COVID 19 pandemic the courts have been operating on two online platforms. WebX and Zoom as well as in-person hearings under certain circumstances.

As a whole, the option to hold remote hearings was incredible. I observed higher participation from the public than pre-pandemic and from what I hear from many people who appear on either platform say they enjoy not having to travel, it is easier to speak to a judge, and they feel that they are on even playing grounds to the attorneys. Some disadvantages range from the court staff having to learn a new way to hold court proceedings, controlling large hearings, and the basic fact that many people do not have access to a phone or internet. Our Supreme Court has attempted to remedy these issues by allowing people to use public computers at the Supreme Court Law Library ((808)-539-4964) but this too is limited by a persons ability to make a call and travel to downtown Honolulu.

I am proud to admit I appeared on Law Week 2021 on behalf of the Young Lawyers Division Hawaii. Please check out the short video on general court procedures.

Law Week 2021: General Court Procedure

Another quick shout out to myself. I got elected to be Vice President of the Alumni Board to the law school I graduated from this month. Cheers!

Hope you all enjoyed this small post. More to come!

Hawaiian word of the day: kuleana: right, privilege, concern, responsibility, title, business, property, estate, portion, jurisdiction, authority, liability, interest, claim, ownership, tenure, affair, province; reason, cause, function, justification.

We have many kuleana. To ourselves, to our friends and family, and to our community. Please take care of one another and do the right thing.

Mahalo and A Hui Hou,

The Aloha Attorney

The California Air Resources Board, also known by its acronym, CARB, has a number of roles. Those roles include protecting the public from harmful effects of air pollution, as well as developing programs and actions to fight climate change in the state of California.

CARB is part of a coordinated three tier approach to cleaning up air pollution in California. The US EPA sets nationwide air quality and emission standards, as well as oversees state efforts and enforcement. Then CARB focuses on California’s unique air quality challenges. It sets the state’s own, stricter emission standards for a wide range of statewide pollution sources, including vehicles, fuels and consumer products. And then there are 35 local air pollution control districts that regulate emissions from businesses and stationary facilities. And these range from oil refineries to auto body shops and even dry cleaners.

CARB is governed by a 16 member board. 12 of those members are appointed by the Governor and confirmed by the State Senate. Of those 12 only one, the Chair of CARB, server on the board full-time. As far as the other eleven members are concerned five must serve on local air districts, four are experts in fields that shape air quality rules, and two are members of the public. The Governor can choose any of the members to serve as Chair of the board. The remaining four CARB members include two people representing environmental justice, or EJ, communities – one of whom is appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules and one by the Speaker of the Assembly – and two non-voting members are appointed for legislative oversight – one each appointed by Senate Rules and the Assembly Speaker.

CARB is established in Health and Safety Code Division 26, Part 2. It’s found in quite a few sections, from section 39500 to 39961. These sections cover many of the Air Resources Board’s duties, which include permit assistance, goods movement, emission reduction program, cruise ships and ocean-going ships, school bus idling, and idling at schools, toxic air contaminants, coordination with federal acts, identification of toxic air contaminants, control of these toxic air contaminants, special provisions for infants and children, its scientific review panel, Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund Investment Plan and Communities Revitalization Act, global warming, and many other critical projects to reduce air pollution and protect public health.

You can read the transcript of the audio in today’s post here.

  1. Introduction

In the twenty-first century, there is an app for everything. Looking to buy more alcohol but do not feel safe driving to your local liquor store to replenish your alcohol supply? No need to worry because there is an app that will deliver alcohol straight to your doorstep. In 2012, three Boston College graduates created the first alcohol delivery app known as “Drizly.” Luke O’Neil, Thursty: A new app called Drizly delivers booze right to your doorstep, Metro.us (May 22, 2013). After completing the initial testing of the app in Massachusetts, the three co-founders expanded its reach to New York, Los Angeles and Chicago. Tom Huddleston, Jr., Ordering on-demand booze is about to get easier, Fortune (May 18, 2015). Today, Drizly is operating in the major cities of thirty states and even Alberta, Canada. Drizly.com (2021). However, Drizly is not alone in the delivery app market with competitors like Swill, Minibar, and Saucey offering similar services. But with Uber’s recent acquisition of Drizly for $1.1 billion, this app seems to be the top market participant. Tom Wark, Why Uber Will Not Be Challenging How Alcohol is Sold and Distributed, Fermentation Wine Blog (Feb. 15, 2021).

So, how does Drizly actually work? After a user downloads the app onto their smartphone device and makes an account, the user is able to search for their desired alcoholic beverage and place an order with one of Drizly’s retail partners. O’Neil, (2013). The retail partner then processes, fulfills, and delivers the order to the consumer within thirty to sixty minutes from the time the consumer finalized their order. Id. From this basic explanation, a few initial concerns are obvious. First, how do alcohol delivery apps fit within the three-tier system and other relevant alcohol regulations? Second, if the app does not fit within the three-tier system, how are Drizly and its competitors cheating the system? The answer to these questions is that they do not fit within the current framework and have carefully crafted their business model to avoid regulation. To be properly regulated, alcohol delivery apps require their own separate fourth tier.

  1. The Laws That Exist Today

There are four areas of the law that are implicated by alcohol delivery apps: the three-tier system, distribution, licensing, and legal drinking age. However, it is important to first understand who has the power to regulate this area and how they do so. The Twenty-First Amendment of the United States Constitution not only repealed the Eighteenth Amendment’s Prohibition, but it also confers onto the states the authority to regulate the transportation and importation of alcoholic beverages. U.S. Const. amend. XXI.  In California, the State’s Constitution vests the Department of Alcohol Beverage Control (“ABC”) with the exclusive power to regulate the manufacture, sale, purchase, possession and transportation of alcohol. CA Const. Art. 20 § 22. The ABC’s regulations can be found in the California Business and Professions Code, Division Nine, commonly known as the “Alcohol Beverage Control Act” (the “Act”) and is a set of permissive statutes. Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 23000-25762. The Act will be the main reference for the laws at issue here.

First, the three-tier system is the area most implicated by alcohol delivery apps. Since the end of Prohibition most states use this regulatory scheme to separate and regulate the different actors in alcohol: manufacturers (tier one), wholesalers (tier two) and retailers (tier three). Gregory E. Durkin, What Does Granholm v. Heald Mean for the Future of the Twenty-First Amendment, the Three-Tier System, and Efficient Alcohol Distribution?, 63 Wash. & Lee L. Rev. 1095, 1097 (2006). The three-tier system generally prohibits any one tier from intermingling with another. Id. This basically means manufacturers cannot directly sell to consumers, instead they must sell their products to licensed wholesalers who then sell the products to licensed retailers. Id. Further, each tier has their own separate set of regulations that permit and prohibit specific conduct.

Second, alcohol distribution is heavily regulated. This area of law can be complicated to understand since some of the more complex regulations are found here such as strict distribution agreement requirements and franchise laws. Further, while all fifty states regulate the sell and distribution of alcohol, they all have different methods in doing so. Regardless of the different state approaches, the three-tier system and tied-house laws generally require distributors to act as the middle-man between producers and retailers. The role of distributors is to sell the manufacturers’ products to retailers, requiring distributors to have sales representatives who visit bars and take orders for multiple different brands (manufacturers) they represent. John Szymankiewicz, Beer Law (2017). The brands they represent make up a wholesaler’s portfolio and it is the wholesaler’s responsibility to sell the brands’ products by investing time and money into each individually. Id. Further, every brand in the portfolio must have entered into a distribution agreement with the wholesaler. Distribution agreements, also called franchise agreements, have multiple mandatory provisions which includes defining an exclusive sales territory and tough termination protections that overwhelmingly favor distributors over brewers. Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 25000.5, 25000.7.

While most states have a mandatory second tier, there are limited exceptions for self-distribution in some states, including California. Like the rest of the Act, self-distribution is heavily regulated. As such, the costs of self-distribution and other factors lead most manufacturers to use a wholesaler. Szymankiewicz, (2017). Nonetheless, there may be some hope for the self-distribution realm. There is current proposed legislation in California that would expand a beer manufacturer’s distribution rights by allowing them to obtain a beer direct shipper permit and ship directly to California consumers. Beer manufacturers: direct shipper permits, Senate Bill No. 517, 2021 Cal. Leg. 2021-2022 Sess.

Third, all players in the alcohol business must obtain a license to participate. Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 23300. The relevant code section provides that “No person shall exercise the privilege or perform any act which a licensee may exercise or perform under the authority of a license unless the person is authorized to do so by a license issued pursuant to this division.” Id. Therefore, any person or entity without a license is prohibited in engaging in any conduct that falls within the ABC’s scope and can face criminal charges for engaging in such conduct. Id. at §23301. Further, an authorized licensee is only permitted to exercise the rights and privileges specified for the license they hold. Id. at §23355.

Finally, all licensees that have the authority to sell alcohol are prohibited from selling to individuals under the legal drinking age of twenty-one. Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 25658. A violation of this law can result in criminal charges and fines up to $1,000. Id. Further, the licensee does not need to have actual knowledge that the individual is not twenty-one to be held liable. Id.

  • How Alcohol Delivery Apps Are Cheating The System

With a basic understanding of the different laws being implicated by alcohol delivery apps, how are alcohol delivery apps cheating the system? The credit is due to their carefully crafted business model. Drizly’s website boasts that their “model is built to be compliant with the regulatory bodies in every state we operate in.” Drizly.com (2021). The most important part of their business model is the partnership relationship between Drizly and local retailers. Drizly’s robust network includes over 4,000 retail partners from coast-to-coast. Id. Furthermore, in 2018 Drizly entered into a partnership with none other than Anheuser-Busch. Drizly Partners with Anheuser-Busch to Stock Office Fridges, Brewbound (July 11, 2018). However, this partnership agreement is different than its regular retailer partnerships as Drizly’s sole job is to stock Anheuser-Busch offices with cold beer. Id. In a regular partnership, Drizly does not actually bring in any profits from the transaction between consumers and retailers. Ni Xu, Drizly: the disruptor of the 3-tier system?, Digital Initiative (Dec. 9, 2015). Instead, Drizly brings in money by charging a monthly license fee to its local retailers. Id. Furthermore, the person who delivers the alcohol to the consumer is not employed by Drizly, but rather the retail partner. Id. Basically, Drizly is simply an interface that retailers use to bring their shelves to the internet which allows consumers to purchase alcohol from wherever they desire.

In light of the three-tier system, where do alcohol delivery apps fit? By not engaging in the actual sale or distribution of alcohol, Drizly and its competitors are able to completely escape regulation. Drizly’s own website states “Drizly was uniquely designed to operate within the three-tier system.” Drizly.com (2021). But is this statement true? The app does not seem to operate within the system, but rather it operates around the system. By strategically not taking any money from the transaction, a delivery app cannot be seen as neither a retailer nor distributor. Instead, they become yet another middle-man, but this time it is between retailers and consumers. While it is natural to see Drizly as a distributor, they stretch the laws even further by avoiding distribution agreements. Again, Drizly’s own website says “we do not guarantee exclusivity to any one store in a given area,” which means they do not enter into distribution agreements with its retail partners. Id. Further, Drizly leaves it up to its retail partners to determine its delivery zone, hours, fees, minimum purchase amounts and more. Id. Drizly’s business model shows that they have carefully reviewed the different states’ alcohol regulations and found a way to operate around the three-tier system and distribution regulations.

Drizly again escapes regulation by not needing a license to operate. In California, the laws require anyone wanting to operate under the Act to obtain a license. Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 23300. The Act defines a wholesaler as “any person other than a manufacturer, winegrower or rectifier who is engaged in business as a jobber or wholesale merchant, dealing in alcoholic beverages…” Id. at § 23021. Further, it gives a weak definition of retailers by considering a retailer to be “any on- or off-sale licensee.” Id. at § 23023. With these working definitions, delivery apps do not seem to fall into either tier, even if the wholesaler definition is analyzed broadly. A delivery app certainly is not a manufacturer, winegrower or rectifier (“a person who colors, flavors or otherwise processes distilled spirits”). Id. at § 23016. But can they be considered jobbers or wholesaler merchants? These terms both define the same concept of distributors: people who buy products in bulk from manufacturers and then resell to retailers. Bob Adams, Wholesalers, Jobbers, Distributors & Importers, BusinessTown (2021). Since the apps do not purchase from alcohol or resell to retailers, they are not wholesalers. Further, delivery apps are not on- or off-sale licensees as they are not the actual business consumers are buying from. Therefore, since delivery apps do not fit within either definition and do not sell or deliver the alcohol, they are not required to obtain a license under the current laws.

Lastly, Drizly uses an identification catalog system called Mident to ensure the person receiving the alcohol is of legal drinking age. Dennis Keohane, How Amazon is getting beat by an upstart alcohol delivery app in its own backyard, Pando (Apr. 8, 2015). Drizly provides its retail partners with a Mident identification scanner which allows the delivery driver to scan the consumer’s ID and confirm the consumer’s age. Id. Thus, without a valid ID proving the consumer is of legal drinking age, they will not be given the alcohol. Furthermore, since Drizly is not involved with the alcohol purchase and the person delivering the alcohol is employed by the retailer, it is the retailer’s responsibility to ensure the person accepting the delivery is twenty-one or older. As such, the final concern is avoided, allowing Drizly and other delivery apps to completely evade state alcohol regulations as they currently exist.

  1. How Alcohol Delivery Apps Affect Craft Breweries

It is still not clear whether alcohol deliveries apps like Drizly have a negative or positive effect on craft breweries. With Drizly being the largest e-commerce alcohol platform in North America and its new owner being Uber, it seems Drizly will likely have a negative effect on small breweries. O’Neil, (2013). While Drizly does not directly determine what products are on a retailer’s shelves, wholesalers will be more likely to sell a certain brand to Drizly’s retail partners because of the positive profits. Further, Drizly tracks consumer drinking habits and regularly publishes reports on the data. Uber Acquires Beer Delivery App Drizly in $1.1 Billion Deal, Hop Culture (Feb. 2, 2021). Therefore, if big beer is selling better through Drizly than craft beer, wholesalers will sell more big beer products to maximize the profits for all three tiers. Also, Drizly and most other alcohol delivery apps currently only operate within major cities. This means that if a craft brewery’s distribution agreement does not reach a major city, they will be excluded from Drizly’s robust market. In order to combat this issue, larger wholesalers will need to start representing more small producers, but this solution is not likely.

  1. The Proposed Solution

The manufacture, sale, purchase, possession and transportation of alcohol is one of the most heavily regulated areas. While the three-tier system is not perfect, it does work in a way to protect craft breweries from being overran by big beer. If lawmakers continue to ignore this sleeping giant, it may eventually become so big that post hoc regulation will be difficult to achieve. Therefore, state legislatures need to act quickly to amend their current three-tier system to find a home for Drizly and its competitors, and that home is a new fourth tier. To actually promote temperance and keep alcohol out of the hands of minors, alcohol delivery apps need to be regulated through the ABC. As of now, a user can order as much alcohol as they like and have it delivered on-demand to their doorstep. As long as the recipient has a valid ID they are able to collect the alcohol order, but it is likely easy to use a fake ID or another person’s ID who is over twenty-one. Lastly, while it is positive that the consumer is not driving under the influence to get more alcohol, should we really promote an app that capitalizes off drunk consumers?

State lawmakers need to add alcohol delivery apps to their regulatory scheme because as of now, this money making machine has evaded regulation. Drizly and its competitors are utilizing a loophole in the ABC by not gaining any profits from the direct sale itself and not employing the delivery drivers. Currently, there are no laws that control alcohol delivery apps from profiting off alcohol and it is clear they do not fit in the normal regulation scheme. Therefore, legislators need to act now to create a fourth tier for Drizly and its competitors to be actually regulated under the Act.