Julienne Correa(Class of 2022)

In the last article about diversity in the law, I discussed the need for diversity within the legal field. Here, I will discuss diversity efforts I have come across through law school.

Diversity fellowships, internships, and scholarships recognize the need for diversity in the legal field by providing equitable platforms for law students. I had no contact with the legal field prior to law school beyond what I learned in the undergraduate pre-law programs, and I was unfamiliar with how law school operated. The three programs discussed below showed me the importance of specific opportunities for diverse students.

Sacramento Bar Association Diversity Fellowship

During my first year, I learned about the Sacramento Bar Association 1L Diversity Fellowship. It encourages diverse law students to apply to firms and promote diversity in the legal field. Diverse students have an opportunity to apply to the fellowship, and if selected are matched with a Sacramento-area private law firm or organization. The program guarantees an interview for each applicant, which allows first-year students to practice interview skills for future opportunities. Further it shows students various firms’ commitment to diversity and inclusion. The program provides an equitable pipeline for diverse students pursuing legal careers in private firms.

McGeorge Diverse Bar Support Stipend  

This past year, I worked on the McGeorge BAR Prep Fund through my position in the McGeorge Unity Caucus. Its goal is to advance diversity by providing financial support to diverse students. A recent Bloomberg article discussed racial differences in Bar Exam passage rates: “By comparison, Whites passed at a rate of 85% in 2019, compared with 74% of Asians, 72% of Native Americans, 69% of Hispanics, and 61% of Blacks.” The fund aims to increase these rates for diverse students.

It recognizes the adverse circumstances that can negatively impact diverse students and decrease passage rates. Through financial assistance, students have one less thing to worry about in this critical time in their law careers.

Just the Beginning Summer Judicial Internship Diversity Project

For my 2L summer, I applied and got accepted for Just the Beginning’s Summer Judicial Internship Diversity Project. The program connects diverse students with judicial internships across the nation. The program’s goal is to create a pipeline for students to pursue judicial externships, clerkships, and eventually, judicial positions. By providing tools, resources, and networks, Just the Beginning aims to diversify the judiciary.

The program began with an assignment to watch a video about what a judicial externship entails and a writing assignment to help students prepare for the externship. This was extremely valuable information because it guided me on what to expect with a judicial externship and practice my writing skills. Additionally, we are invited to seminars discussing a variety of legal topics and advice on how to pursue a career in the judiciary. The program provided guidance throughout my externship.

Finding these opportunities made me feel supported through my law school journey. It aims to diversify the legal field by providing students with tools and equitable resources to excel in their legal career.

L-R Front row: Marisa Uribe (UC Davis) and Stephanie Allen (McGeorge). Back row: Omar Figueroa (McGeorge), Emma James (McGeorge), and Matthew Lanthier (UC Davis).

The Yolo County District Attorney’s Office welcomed three McGeorge students to its 2021 Summer/Fall internship program: Stephanie Allen (3L), Emma James (2L), and Omar Figueroa (2L); along with two other law students from UC Davis. After a year of remote work, the Yolo County District Attorney’s Office is excited to re-open its doors for in-person internships and externships. Students participating in the program have the opportunity to gain valuable hands-on experience working under the mentorship of practicing attorneys with real clients. You can read the Office’s full press release here.

The California Citizens Redistricting Commission (“CRC”) is charged with completing the decennial job of drawing district lines for state Senators, state Assemblymembers, members of the U.S. House of Representatives, and the California State Board of Equalization (“BOE”) members. Article XXI of the California Constitution established the CRC. Article XXI describes the redistricting of the Senate, Assembly, Congressional, and BOE districts every 10 years. In 2008, Proposition 11 amended Article XXI, which now has three major sections.

Section 1 states the year after the national census is taken, the Citizens Redistricting Commission must adjust the boundary lines of the Congressional, state Senate, Assembly, and Board of Equalization. This ensures district conform with the standards and process set forth in this Article XXI of the California Constitution.

Section 2 explains the CRC must conduct an open and transparent process, which enables full public consideration and comments concerning the drawing of district lines. The CRC draws district lines according to the redistricting criteria specified in Article XXI. Also according to Section 2, each commissioner must be a registered voter in California for at least five years with the same political affiliation.

Section 3 provides that the CRC is the sole legal standing to defend any action regarding a certified final map. The commission must inform the Legislature if funds or other resources are not adequate, the Legislature then must provide adequate funding to defend any action regarding any of the certified maps.

You can find the full transcript of the audio in today’s podcast here.

On July 1, 2021, McGeorge Legal Clinics welcomed Assistant Clinical Professor of Law, Ron S. Hochbaum as the first-ever director of the Homeless Advocacy Clinic. We asked him to tell us a little about himself, his work and his teaching philosophy.

Tell us how you got into your line of work.

Although I went to law school on the East Coast, I knew I wanted to practice in California. My law school did not have the resources or connections to help me secure an internship in California, so I took it upon myself. I periodically bought plane tickets and would cold call or e-mail public interest attorneys asking to see if they would be willing to grab a coffee and give me advice on breaking into the public interest community in California.

One of these unsolicited e-mails turned into an internship at the Homeless Action Center in Berkeley. The internship was transformative experience that introduced me to client-centered and community lawyering models. I stayed in touch with the attorneys at the Homeless Action Center all throughout law school and when I graduated, they hired me as a staff attorney. I have been advocating on behalf of homeless individuals ever since. This experience is why I am always encouraging my students to grow their networks in the legal community.

What is your favorite part of clinical work?

Watching students develop their confidence. For many students, clinic is the first time they will talk to a client and engage in the real work of lawyering. Most come to the experience frightened and uncertain. In clinic, I can provide the scaffolding students need to explore their lawyering abilities and professional identities. Over the course of the year, a student’s confidence grows and grows. By the end of the year, most are ready to “spread their wings and fly”; it’s a joy and privilege to be a part of.

What is the hardest part of clinical work?

Saying goodbye to students and clients. As lawyers, we are often taught to keep our clients and their issues at arm’s length. However, the assumptions underlying that lesson are often detached from the reality of legal practice. Our clients are coming to us during some of the most challenging moments in their lives. For many of us, especially those of us in the public interest community, we are passionate about our work. It is not just a job but a vocation. That is why I started taking the advice of one of my mentors and teach a class on the end of attorney-client relationships. Honoring the nature of the relationship and putting as much intentionality into the end as the beginning of the attorney-client relationship yields numerous benefits. My experiences with students are no different. The low student-teacher ratio in clinic allows us to develop close bonds. We celebrate the highs and commiserate over the lows of our shared work. When I say goodbye to students it is bittersweet. I know they are ready for the next opportunity but I secretly hope we are just saying “goodbye for now” and that they continue to stay in touch over the course of their careers.

What advice can you give to students in order to have a successful experience in your clinic?

Listen to your clients and practice non-judgmentally. For most of us, our clients day-to-day and lived experiences are wildly different than our own. In my experience, when students truly listen to their clients, they learn more about the world than I ever could have hoped to teach them. Through this experience they will also start to interrogate the culture of stigma constructed around homelessness. Once that veil is lifted, we are better equipped to practice non-judgmentally and meet our clients “where they are at.” These two simple but oft-ignored methods will enrich students’ clinical learning experiences and provide them the foundations for their future practice.

Who has been the biggest influence in your legal career and what did they teach you?

My former supervisors at the Homeless Action Center – David Waggoner, Mary Gilg, Kris Chappel, and Pattie Wall. David, Mary, Kris, and Pattie taught me how to practice barrier-free and holistically. They taught me to reject the superficial and misguided hurdles service providers frequently erect for clients that not only frustrate our advocacy but also ensure that prospective clients who are most in need and hardest to reach go unserved. This approach to lawyering requires us to deconstruct hierarchies and remind ourselves that just because we do not charge for our services does not mean that we have license to impose expectations upon our clients while disregarding their expectations of us.

What excited you the most about the new Homeless Advocacy Clinic at McGeorge?

The faculty and administration at McGeorge deserve tremendous credit for establishing this clinic. Although law school clinics have been serving homeless clients since the birth of clinical legal education, there are only a handful of clinics at law schools across the country that exclusively serve homeless individuals. Dean Michael Schwartz, Professor Melissa Brown, and Professor Dorothy Landsberg’s work to establish this clinic is indicative of their visionary leadership and dedication to making sure the Law School’s Clinical Program responds to Sacramento and California’s most critical needs.

Moreover, I believe the Homeless Advocacy Clinic will provide tremendously engaging and enriching learning experiences for students while offering vital legal services for underrepresented Sacramentans. Working on cases for unhoused clients will allow students to apply the theories they learned in the first year or two of law school to real world practice. They will hone their lawyering skills, like interviewing, counseling, legal writing, and oral advocacy, while providing compassionate and empowering representation to their clients.

What do you do for fun?

I love to travel and eat. I have lived on four different continents and traveled to about twenty-five different countries and thirty states. When we cannot get away, you can usually find me and my partner, Mari, trying new restaurants and cooking delicious vegan meals. We are new to Sacramento and taking recommendations!

As of July 9, 2021, 18 states have legalized marijuana for recreational use and 36 states have legalized marijuana for medical use. Despite a trend where states are becoming more welcoming towards marijuana, it remains federally illegal. This means that lawful marijuana use can have disastrous immigration consequences–even in states where marijuana use is legal.

Furthermore, lawful employment in the marijuana industry may make non-citizens ineligible for certain forms of relief. Although President Biden stood for decriminalization of marijuana during his campaign, the Biden administration has not yet formulated policy changes regarding marijuana.

Non-citizens should avoid marijuana use in any form until they become a United States citizen, as this is the best guarantee against negative immigration consequences. This includes marijuana use for medical purposes.

Non-citizens should also avoid all employment in the marijuana industry. Though it is a rapidly growing industry, employment in the marijuana industry is risky for non-citizens. Examples of employment includes harvesting, sales, working for dispensaries, transportation and delivery.

Additionally, non-citizens should avoid storing marijuana-related photos on their phones or uploading marijuana-related content on social media. Non-citizens should  also avoid possessing marijuana or marijuana paraphernalia, either inside or outside of their homes. For more tips, see the video by Immigrant Legal Resource Center below.

If you have questions about marijuana and your status, you can also contact us at (916) 340-6080 to see if you qualify for a consultation at our Immigration Clinic.

About the Author

Jordan Mickele-Niemoeller is currently a rising third-year student at University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law. He has been a student attorney in the Immigration clinic since Summer 2020. 

Act I, Scene IV: Jerman v. Carlisle, McNellie, Rini, Kramer, & Ulrich LPA

Hold the presses: it’s another case involving debt collection! In case you haven’t yet, check out “How Debt Collectors are Transforming the Business of State Courts.” Basically, about 1 in 4 civil cases brought to state court is related to debt collection, the total number of cases continues to increase, and most result in default judgments. Translation: attorneys for debt buying agencies are filing suit against unrepresented parties for debts that may belong to someone else, they may have already paid, or they may be unable to pay. Charming.

Thankfully, Congress enacted the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) “to eliminate abusive debt collection practices, to ensure that debt collectors who abstain from such practices are not competitively disadvantaged, and to promote consistent state action to protect consumers.” Good job, Congress! Only wait… this was passed in 1977 and the problem is worse than ever. I guess keep collecting your paychecks and thank you for your service?

Anywhoozle! Back to our case. The thrilling question: whether the “bona fide error” defense, codified in section 1692k(c) applies to a violation resulting from a debt collector’s mistaken interpretation of the legal requirements of the FDCPA.

Section 813(c) of the Act, 15 U. S. C. §1692k(c), provides that a debt collector is not liable in an action brought under the Act if she can show “the violation was not intentional and resulted from a bona fide error notwithstanding the maintenance of procedures reasonably adapted to avoid any such error.”

Pause. I’ll translate in a minute. First, let’s tackle the elephant in the room: how to pronounce “bona fide.” According to Oxford, we’ve got four options to tackle this Latin phrase:

  1. bōnə ˌfīd. Is this the most common? Maybe it’s regional?
  2. ˈbänə ˌfīd. The short “O” feels more relaxed. Plus, I used to think it was “banafide” so this makes sense to me!
  3. bōnə ˈfīdē. Incredibly Latin, fun to say, plus a bit snobby. Professor Haynes pronounced it this way in class once and I was so distracted that I have no idea what we covered.
  4. bōnə ˈfēdā. Now with even more Latin! Never heard it.

Returning to the question, there’s an easier way to ask it: does the FDCPA provide a mistake-of-law defense to civil liability? Can someone who misunderstanding or misapplies the law avoid penalties when someone brings suit? Nope.

[I]gnorance of the law will not excuse any person, either civilly or criminally. Barlow v. United States

Most interesting to me, is the fact that an error occurs despite “procedures reasonably adapted to avoid any such error.” Despite all the checks put in place a mistake still happens. That’s fine, so long as is not a misunderstanding or misapplication of the law. So, what was the error that Carlisle committed that got us here in the first place?

Karen L. Jerman had a mortgage (emphasis on had, as Karen had already paid it in full). Carlisle sought foreclosure! That escalated quickly and also, doesn’t make any sense knowing what we know (remember, Karen had ALREADY paid off the mortgage). In their efforts to foreclose on Karen’s real property, Carlisle included a “Notice” that stated “the mortgage debt would be assumed valid unless Jerman disputed it in writing.” Yikes. Thankfully, Karen hired a lawyer who sent a letter “disputing the debt” (remember, Karen had ALREADY paid off the mortgage). Karen’s mortgagor, Countrywide Home Loans, acknowledged full payment and Carlisle withdrew the foreclosure suit.

Taking a step back, someone who PAID OFF their mortgage receives a piece of mail that says “This mortgage debt will be assumed valid unless you dispute it in writing.” Doesn’t that smell scammy? Plus, it’s total nonsense because the homeowner knows they’ve already PAID OFF their mortgage. What if Karen had thought it was just some junk mail and shredded it? Carlisle would have received a default judgment, meaning that the undisputed mortgage debt was valid and delinquent. Carlisle could have proceeded with foreclosure. That’s how the system works! It’s absurd.

This case also raised my skeptical eyebrow because of Rule 11(b).

By presenting to the court a pleading, written motion, or other paper—whether by signing, filing, submitting, or later advocating it—an attorney or unrepresented party certifies that to the best of the person’s knowledge, information, and belief, formed after an inquiry reasonable under the circumstances:

(1) it is not being presented for any improper purpose, such as to harass, cause unnecessary delay, or needlessly increase the cost of litigation;

(2) the claims, defenses, and other legal contentions are warranted by existing law or by a nonfrivolous argument for extending, modifying, or reversing existing law or for establishing new law;

(3) the factual contentions have evidentiary support or, if specifically so identified, will likely have evidentiary support after a reasonable opportunity for further investigation or discovery; and

(4) the denials of factual contentions are warranted on the evidence or, if specifically so identified, are reasonably based on belief or a lack of information.

The lawyers did not conduct “an inquiry reasonable under the circumstances…” because their “factual contentions” totally lacked “evidentiary support,” as an “reasonable opportunity for further investigation or discovery” from their client would show that Karen had already paid off her mortgage. The complete lack of due diligence means that filing this complaint only served to harass Karen and other former mortgagees. Certification of this complaint by attorneys at this firm should have resulted in sanctions.

Oh, but that can’t just happen. Karen’s attorney would have needed to file a Motion for Sanctions under Rule 11(c)(2).

A motion for sanctions must be made separately from any other motion and must describe the specific conduct that allegedly violates Rule 11(b). The motion must be served under Rule 5, but it must not be filed or be presented to the court if the challenged paper, claim, defense, contention, or denial is withdrawn or appropriately corrected within 21 days after service or within another time the court sets. If warranted, the court may award to the prevailing party the reasonable expenses, including attorney’s fees, incurred for the motion.

Despite the harassing nature of filing complaints bringing foreclosure action against former mortgagees who have already paid of their mortgages, a motion for sanctions must not be filed or presented if the complaint is challenged and then dropped within 21 days after service of the answer, motion to dismiss, or some other action by the former mortgagee. So, even if Karen thinks this conduct is horrific, as long as the firm withdraws the suit within the time period, Karen is barred from filing for sanctions.

For the the people in the back: a mortgage company hires a law firm, a law firm sues “delinquent” clients of mortgage company, Karen (a former mortgagee) is not delinquent, Karen hires an attorney to say so to the law firm, law firm drops suit after mortgage company verifies that Karen is not delinquent. And the Supremes, in their infinite wisdom, focus on whether requiring the reply challenging the outstanding debt be in writing is an unfair debt collection practice (because it violates the legal requirements within the FDCPA). Despite the fact that a simple inquiry by the law firm could have prevented this entire interaction, Karen probably couldn’t file for sanctions under Rule 11(c). Karen was able to keep the property, but think about what she had to go through to hold on to it.

Surprise to no one, John Oliver talked about debt buyers and this mess back in 2016:

Also, I cannot believe we live in a world where Debt Collector gets a sequel… Debt Collectors:

The Ethics in Government Act of 1990 contains four different articles:

Article 1: Honoraria

Article 2: Gifts

Article 3: Travel

Article 4: Campaign Funds

Article 1 defines honoraria as any payment made in consideration for a speech that is given, any article that is published, or attendance at a public or private conference, convention, meeting, social event, meal, or similar gathering. However, earned income for personal services, which are customarily provided in connection with the practice of a bonafide business trade or profession are excluded from the definition. The law prohibits any elected official, including a state officer, local government agency, or other specified individuals from receiving honorarium. In addition, no candidate for elected state office, for judicial office, or for elected office in a local government agency is allowed to accept any honorarium.

Article 2 prohibits elected officials from accepting gifts with a total value of more than $250 in any calendar year from a single source. In addition, no member of a state board or commission, certain designated state employees, or local government agencies are allowed to accept gifts in a calendar year from a single source for more than $250 adjusted annually. This amount is adjusted for inflation every year based on the California Consumer Price Index. In 2020, the amount is over $500. The law does not prohibit or limit payments, advances, or reimbursements for travel and lodging, or for wedding gifts, or gifts that are exchanged between individuals on birthdays, holidays, or similar occasions provided that the gifts exchanged are not substantially disproportionate in value.

Article 3 provides that any payments, advances or reimbursements for travel that are for actual transportation and related lodging and subsistence, must be reasonably related to a legislative or governmental purpose or to an issue of state, national or international public policy.

Article 4 requires candidates for elected state office to only accept contributions within the specified limits of the law. Campaign contributions in a campaign account are deemed to be held in trust for expenses associated with the election of that candidate or for expenses associated with holding that particular office. The rest of this article four basically sets forth the use of campaign funds for specific expenditures. For example, campaign funds may not be used to pay or reimburse the candidate or the elected officer or any individual who has authority to spend the campaign funds for travel expenses, except those that are directly related to a political legislative or governmental purpose.

You can find the full transcript of the audio in today’s podcast here.

 

In 1951 California passed the District Organization Law. The law created a procedure for the organization, operation, and government of districts in the state of California. This applies when and to the extent that it’s adopted or incorporated by reference in a law providing for a particular district or type of district in the state of California. A notice is required to be published once a week for three successive and proof of publication is required. It can be done by affidavit of the owner, publisher, printer or clerk of the newspaper.

Article Two deals with petitions and the formation proceedings. The proceedings begin when a petition is filed with the supervising authority. In Section 58,034, there are five requirements for the petition to meet. Article Three deals with preliminary hearings. This includes the requirement that the supervising authority must fix a time and place for hearings.

Article Four describes the final hearing. The law requires the supervising authority to specify the time and place for the final hearing on the petition. At the hearing any owner of land in the proposed district may present to the supervising authority a written request for exclusion of all or part of the land. The law requires the clerk publish notice of inclusion to the address of the owner of the land as shown on the county assessment rule.

Article Five involves the formation of districts. The law requires the supervising authority to call and give notice of an election within 20 days after adopting the resolution for the proposed district. The clerk is required to file a certified copy of the resolution with California’s Secretary of State. The organization of the district is complete once the clerk provides a certified copy of the resolution to the Secretary of State.

You can find the full transcript of the audio in today’s podcast here.

A couple years ago we shared a post about law student business cards. Since that time, a rather large event has occurred that may affect the demand for law students to carry business cards: the COVID-19 pandemic. With many people still wary of transmitting and catching the virus from contact with physical surfaces, not to mention the slough of new variants that seem to be discovered every other week, it’s fair to wonder if law students should bother getting business cards. However, it looks like the business card is one of those things that just won’t go away – after all, business cards have been around since the 17th century and survived through many epidemics already.

While many people may still be wary of handshakes and touching public surfaces, an old-fashioned business card is still an important tool for successful professionals, lawyers included. There have been a few waves of “digital business cards” throughout the years that would have been great for today’s world, but none of them were able to stick around for long (remember Bump?). One of the problems with these products is that there will always be security risks involved when connecting two smart devices; but likely the biggest inhibitor to going with fully digital business cards – at least for the time being – isthe fact that some lawyers and judges may not be as comfortable with new tech and smart devices as millennials and Gen Z-ers. Asking them to exchange information via Apple’s AirDrop function, Bluetooth, or a QR code can end up being much more of a hassle than simply handing over a piece of cardstock. Whenyou’re a law student or new lawyer still developing your network of mentors, making the exchange of information as easy as possible for the people you connect with is more important than your own convenience.

As we’ve mentioned before, the purpose of a law student’s business card isn’t to prompt the recipient to contact you. Instead, it should simply remind them of who you are when you reach out, and hopefully they’ll be able to recall your conversation. Business cards can play an even bigger role in this if you were only able to briefly chat with an attorney or judge, and you quickly exchanged cards before going your separate ways. For example, perhaps you had a productive but quick chat with an attorney in the hallway between court observations. Having a business card to offer will help them remember you when you follow up that 2-minute conversation with a phone call or email later.

The business card may seem like a relic of the past, but it will continue to have its uses for law students and lawyers alike. Every fall semester, McGeorge students have access to buy custom business cards through MOO.com. If you need assistance figuring out what information should go on your card, make an appointment with a CDO advisor to help you create something that will leave a memorable impression on whoever receives it. Perhaps we’ll see a time in the future where physical business cards are no more and digital cards are commonplace, but for now we continue to rely on the tried-and-true method.

Are you looking for a unique post-bar opportunity? 2Ls, 3Ls, and recent graduates should consider using the summer to apply for project-based fellowships, that typically begin in the fall (often one year out). Fellowships are highly competitive and provide a unique opportunity to jumpstart a career in law, so it’s never too early to start planning. Fellows are able to use their legal skills to affect positive change for disadvantaged populations while receiving top-rate training and supervision. You’ll further refine many of the skills developed through externships and clinics, and the experience will be very desirable when applying for future positions. PSJD gave some great tips last summer which still apply today, on how to begin your fellowship search and how to organize your project with a funding organization and a host organization. You should also contact the McGeorge Career Development Office to refine your application materials and take advantage of our connections with a number of organizations and contacts across the nation.