The Elder and Health Law (EHL) clinic, a civil practice clinic serving those age 60 and older, offers clients legal representation on matters including protection from physical and financial abuse, estate and end-of-life planning, contract disputes and more. In 2020 alone, the clinic recovered and/or protected $1,424,190 in assets for elders and fine/fees forgiveness.

Ten students joined the Elder & Health Law Clinic (ELHC) in the fall, which expanded to twelve this spring. Lacey Mickleburgh our fearless staff attorney and clinical fellow, Kendell Bennet, rounded out the team. Although COVID-19 presented significant access to the courts, student attorneys were able to assist and represent elders in a variety of legal matters. Cases included estate planning and powers of attorney to give peace of mind to their clients, consumer protection from suspect businesses, elder abuse restraining orders and elder financial abuse litigation.

During this period, the courts were not accepting cases other than requests for elder abuse, domestic violence, or civil harassment restraining orders. Because elders are often the targets of undue influence and false promises, many transfer their homes, their only asset, to family or friends. The ELHC was able to protect these assets through a restraining order and order to re-convey the property to our client. This novel and creative approach saved three homes from sale, and our clients from being evicted from their own homes.

When the courts did open up for trials, student attorneys achieved major settlements in three financial abuse cases, each in the heat of litigation. Students took depositions, propounded and responded to discovery, filed motions and briefs; all of which let to successful results for happy clients. They, successfully represented a client in a multi-day Zoom trial and helped recover substantial assets that had been taken from them. The case began in 2019 and took the efforts of multiple students who assisted with depositions, trial preparation, and more.

During 2020-2021, McGeorge Legal Clinics continued to represent individual clients in spite of the challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic, providing essential services to vulnerable members of our community who have no place else to turn. There is no way our clients would have had access to the courts without the advocacy provided by our Legal Clinics. The grit, dedication, creativity, and resourcefulness of our Student Attorneys has been remarkable.

On campus, Community Legal Services, McGeorge’s year-round legal clinic, provides pro bono legal services to the greater Sacramento community in the areas of Immigration, Bankruptcy, and Elder & Health Law. This March, we celebrated one full year at our new home, on 2925 34th Street. Last year, CLS closed 236 cases for 586 low-income clients in the Sacramento area. Since 2019, CLS has recovered 2.75 million for financially exploited elders and 1.7 million in discharged consumer debt. Off campus, our Legislative & Public Policy Clinic, Prisoner Civil Rights Medication Clinic and Federal Defender Clinic students continue to show equally impressive results.

In June 2020, we welcomed our first-ever graduate legal fellows. Not only did they work diligently at CLS, they studied for and each passed the October bar exam. Four for four! I am so proud of their success and the contributions they have made and will continue to make to the legal profession.

Despite being isolated from friends, colleagues, professors, and resources, our Student Attorneys illustrated their commitment to social justice by providing zealous advocacy. Thank you to our students, staff attorneys, post-graduate fellows, legal coordinator and clinical colleagues for another successful and impactful year. Despite a most challenging year, you persevered in providing high-quality legal services to the community.

The past year has posed some unique challenges to law students. Chiefly, the shift from in-person to at-home learning required most of us to adapt to our learning environment. But we have also adapted similarly at least once before: when we started law school.

If you are like me, your undergrad study habits were day and night different from those you had to adopt in law school. But just because transitioning to law school or adapting to virtual learning can be daunting, it’s not impossible. And there are tools that I have found make a significant difference when it comes to cutting out distractions and organizing all of my drafts, outlines, class slides, notes, and work files.

Today, I want to share the top five resources that I have used for the past three years. These tools are not exclusively used for law school, so feel free to apply them at work or while pursuing your undergraduate degree. Most of these suggestions can be used for school, work, or just personal use. So, let’s get into the list:

1. Note Taking

Some of you may see this section and think “Why is this #1? I already have a notebook and pen to take notes.” No doubt you are one of the many who prefer to take notes by handwriting them. And of course, most people are likely aware of the research suggesting that handwritten notes increase a person’s understanding and retention of the material. More on that here.

And if you still want to handwrite your notes, I would suggest getting a tablet and e-pen. For instance, I use my iPad and Apple Pencil to handwrite notes during class that I can then transcribe and add to outlines or other study resources.

But notebooks are bulky. Pens get lost. There is no way to transfer those written notes into an outline. That is why having a note-taking app on your computer and/or tablet is so important. These apps allow you to type notes, copy/paste them, organize them in books, binders, pages, cards, and several other digital formats.

Here are the apps that I would suggest:

One Note

At OU Law, all of our students have Office 365 accounts with access to the complete suite of apps. One of Microsoft’s most popular tools is One Note. One Note is an open format note-taking space. It allows the user to organize notes into folders with subsections that contain each individual “page.” And I say “page” because there are no page breaks. You have a vast expanse to dump as many notes as you want into.

I suggest One Note because I use it as part of my Office 365 suite. It stores all my notes on a cloud server so I can access and edit them from any of my devices. The fact that it synchronizes with all of my other Microsoft apps is a massive convenience.

Evernote

I used Evernote in Undergrad. From what I recall, it is a good note-taking app that allows for plenty of personalized organization and formatting. The primary reason I switched to One Note over Evernote was the fact that I use Microsoft apps almost exclusively like a majority of the legal profession does. However, that does not mean that Evernote deserves to be discarded. If you prefer a different interface and aesthetic that One Note doesn’t offer, check out Evernote.

Craft

This one is pretty new. Craft is an iOS app that I use to take notes and organize my podcast projects, blog ideas, and personal book studies. I have, so far, really enjoyed the functionality and organization of Craft because it allows me to move content freely on each document. Also, it allows the user to create pages and cards within documents that contain additional content. If you are a visual learner, or if you juggle more creative responsibilities in an iOS environment, I would suggest trying it out.

2. Cloud Storage

I mentioned this briefly in the previous section, but it definitely deserves a place on this list. Cloud storage isn’t new, and it keeps growing more relevant. For a brief explanation, storing your data on the cloud means that you are most likely saving it on an encrypted server owned and protected by a company that enables you to access it through the internet. These services allow you to access and edit your documents from almost any device from anywhere with a connection to the internet.

I can’t even begin to adequately emphasize the importance of auto-save during law school. Auto-save is a function that most cloud services offer that will track your changes to a document and save them in real-time. This means that if your computer dies or crashes after you just spent hours drafting an outline, your progress will be saved!

Of course, all cloud services will offer slightly different experiences, so I would first suggest using the one you are most comfortable with. However, I would also be remiss if I didn’t also stress the importance of vetting the security of the service. If you work with or have sensitive data, make sure that the service you use has adequate security. Multiple server locations also protect your data against loss due to natural disasters.

Suggestions:

I won’t go into too much detail on my suggestions for these because I think it really depends on how well the service you use integrates with the rest of your apps and software. But, I do suggest either OneDrive or Google Drive for students, because they both allow you to work collaboratively and they will auto-save your work when you edit on the cloud. If you are using a cloud service for work, I would suggest using a business account, which will provide better encryption and security.

3. Ambient Noise

Alright, this one is big for me. I took a lot of online classes in undergrad and obviously have taken a majority of classes virtually since the COVID outbreak last March. That means I spend a lot of time at my computer, at home, surrounded by distractions. One way I stay focused; ambient noise. For me, this works best with the sound of a breeze, rain, thunder, a crackling fire, or some repetitive melody. If you are interested, you can read an article about the effect of background noise on studying here.

Suggestions:

Again, this one really depends on what you find most useful. There are so many apps and webpages that provide ambient noise that trying to name and differentiate them in a blog post would be foolhardy. However, I will say that there are three platforms that I am likely to turn to which depends on the project that I am working on at the moment.

Brain Fm

If you are a science fan, you will probably like this one. Brain FM is a premium service that offers ambient music scientifically developed to improve brain function and information retention. I have used this when I need to dig deep into class readings or extensive legal research. If you are interested but not ready to pay for the service, Brain FM does offer a three-day free trial.

Noiisy

The app I use most often is Noiisy. Noiisy allows me to mix my own ambient noises by selecting what sounds to include and adjust their respective levels. I enjoy this especially because it allows me to decide exactly what I want to hear. I also use this for providing ambiance when I read at night or am having trouble falling asleep. It also includes a timer to set your playback to anything from 1 to 120 minutes. And it’s free!

YouTube

If you don’t know where to start, and you don’t want to install an app, you can always turn to YouTube! YouTube is famous for having a massive library by creators in nearly every corner of the internet. This includes a massive library of hours-long ambient noise mixes. Any time I want to mix it up, I will go to youtube and browse its libraries until I find something that appeals to me. And, again, it is free!

4. Password Manager

You should have unique, strong passwords for all of your accounts on the internet, which, admittedly, can seem almost impossible. In law school, you are going to accumulate a lot of new logins. A lot. So, how are you supposed to come up with passwords for all of those sites? Come up with one good one and just apply it to all of them? No.

Instead, you should get yourself a password manager to help you create and save your login information. This way, all of your accounts will be more secure, and you won’t have to consistently go looking for your old passwords. They will all be in one place! I cannot stress how useful a password manager is when you use several different legal research sites, class pages, and personal accounts like Netflix, or Disney+, or Amazon Prime. And if you aren’t convinced yet, take a look at this article by the NY Times about why you need a password manager.

Suggestions:

First, I would decide how much you are willing to pay for a password manager. Because you will have to pay for a really good one. But they are not all that expensive in comparison to the security they provide. I am comfortable suggesting both 1Password and LastPass, but if you are interested in exploring more options you can start with this guide.

5. Browser Extension

Now, it is time to talk about the window you will spend most of your time using; your browser. I use Google Chrome because it has always been the most reliable browser in my opinion, although Safari has improved lately and is the other browser that I use more for personal browsing. Chrome offers a vast market of extensions that run within your browser window and offer added functionality. For me, these are the extensions that have added the most value to my browser:

PowerNotes

If you have ever conducted academic research online, you know the struggle of copy/pasting information and keeping it organized. If you ever thought “there has to be a better way to do this” then you are right. PowerNotes was created to specifically help law students and lawyers organize their research by developing a tool that works within your browser. This means that you can read a case on Westlaw, Lexis, Bloomberg, or anywhere on the internet and save it directly to your outline. For me, it has saved me a ton of time and streamlined my research process because I don’t have to constantly switch windows to save my research. If you do any research and drafting, check out PowerNotes.

Momentum

Do you like pretty pictures and motivational quotes? Then download Momentum. Momentum is an extension that changes your default new tab page with a daily photo and mantra. You can also personalize it with your name, show the weather for your location, and run a to-do list on it. I enjoy the relaxing and stunning photography that it uses. It is always nice to have a peaceful screen when you are in the middle of a stressful project or just starting. Momentum helps me be productive and find some peace of mind at the same time. And it is available on several browsers!

Grammarly

Of course, no list of browser extensions would be complete without mentioning Grammarly. After all, we are all human, and we make mistakes. So, let Grammarly help out and flag any misspelled words, comma splices, or conflicting verb usage. I won’t go into depth on this because I feel like most everyone has enough of an understanding of what it offers.

I hope you have found something valuable from this blog. Again, any of these suggestions are freely offered for students of any variety as well as attorneys or other professionals. Ultimately, I see these apps and tools as ways to improve productivity and reduce overall stress.

In craft beer law, one of the most aggravating and seemingly unstoppable issues we see is Big Manufacturers’ constant efforts to undermine, diminish, and erode tied-house laws through the legislative process. Here we go again.

California Assembly Bill AB-1070 (Irwin), introduced on February 18, 2021, is shining example of the shenanigans that deep pockets empower Big Manufacturers to engage in.  The Bill provides as follows [with my bracketed insertions]: “This bill would authorize specified licensees [manufacturers], without direct or indirect charge, to give up to 12 retail advertising umbrellas to an on-sale retail licensee [bars and restaurants], per licensed location [all locations the bar or restaurant has], each calendar year for use at the location [a new set of umbrellas every year!].  This bill would prohibit the retail advertising umbrellas from exceeding the value of $250 per unit [LOL] and would prescribe other requirements in this regard.”

Ask yourself who would want this. Do you think your local craft brewery could afford to give even one $250 umbrella to each of the retail locations that serve its beer? When you multiply $250 by 12, you get $3000. Really? A free $3000 worth of fancy umbrellas? This would be yet another major exception to the tied-house laws.

The primary purpose of tied-house laws is to prevent Big Manufacturers from having undue influence over retailers. See Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 25500 et seq. The primary restriction to achieve this goal is to prohibit manufacturers from giving “anything of value” to retailers so that retailers will not be subject to pressure to favor certain brands over others. In addition, California’s alcoholic beverage control scheme, like most states’ schemes, seeks to promote temperance in the consumption of alcoholic beverages.  See id. at § 23000.

AB-1070 (Irwin) patently flies in the face of the legislative purposes behind tied-house laws and California’s alcoholic beverage control scheme. Does allowing manufacturers who can afford to give $3000 x [add up as many on-premise locations as you wish] further the goals of reducing undue pressure on retailers or promote temperance? Nope. Not at all.

Instead, this reflects a larger plan that Big Manufacturers have effectively employed over time to snuff out the pesky little guy. The more exceptions to the tied-house restrictions that Big Manufacturers can pass, the less veracity the whole system has—exactly what Big Manufacturers want. If there are no restrictions on Big Manufacturers giving away free stuff (even money in some cases), the pressure on retailers to push their products, and only their products, will be insurmountable. A small mom-and-pop, or even a large chain restaurant, would be hard pressed to deny such enticing freebies—especially when the Big Manufacturer can quickly supply its own shiny and new crafty beers from the formerly independent brewery down the street that it just bought (with no reference to ownership, of course).

Two cycles ago, it was free glassware; now it is free branded umbrellas. Anyone seeing a pattern? Educate your legislators. This is ridiculous.

While the First-Amendment gets a lot of the constitutional attention in craft beer law in terms of advertising restrictions, another constitutional issue has been stealing some of that focus recently.  More specifically, the Dormant Commerce Clause has been the subject of several high-profile litigation matters across the country. To be transparent, the Dormant Commerce Clause is the subject of a new law review article that I am working on for the summer, but I digress.

So what is the Dormant Commerce Clause? In fact, it is no clause at all. Rather, the Dormant Commerce Clause has been inferred by the Supreme Court as a restriction on states’ ability to favor in-state commerce over out-of-state competitors. The Commerce Clause grants Congress the power to regulate interstate commerce; but the Dormant Commerce Clause acts conversely and prohibits states from favoring their own at the expense of out-of-state actors through either prohibitions or unduly burdening interstate commerce. Boiled down and simplified, any state law that affects interstate commerce must not (1) discriminate against out-of-state competition or favor in-state actors, and (2) must not “unduly burden” interstate commerce. There are a few notable exceptions for important local interests like health and safety.

How does the Dormant Commerce Clause impact craft beer? Most, if not all, states prohibit beer manufacturers from shipping beer out of state and prohibit importing alcoholic beverages without going through a licensed wholesaler/importer. This obviously impacts interstate commerce by favoring in-state manufacturers over out-of-state manufacturers. As one example, California Business & Professions Code section 23661 prohibits direct shipments of alcoholic beverages from manufacturers outside of California into California without much procedural morass and licensing.  See also Bus. & Prof. Code § 23661.3 (allowing direct shipments of wine only if the manufacturer complies with wine shipment permitting requirements). But California breweries cannot directly ship beer to consumers outside of California, and breweries outside of California cannot directly ship their beer to California consumers.  Does that seem fair? Does it seem like favoring one group over another?  It should.

Several lawsuits have popped up recently concerning the direct shipping conundrum, and each of them have raised the Dormant Commerce Clause to argue that such laws disfavor out-of-state manufacturers or that they unduly burden interstate commerce. The United States Supreme Court recently denied certiorari in Lebamoff Enterprises, Inc. v. Whitmer which argued the Dormant Commerce Clause prohibited Michigan’s restrictive import/export laws that allows in-state retailers to sell wine online but prohibits out-of-state retailers from doing so.  See Mich. Comp. L. § 436.1203(3)(15); see also Lebamoff Enterp., Inc. v. Whitmer, — U.S. –, 2021 WL 78088 (denying certiorari).  In addition, the Ninth Circuit just this week upheld California’s Section 23661 that requires retailers to source their alcohol from in-state wholesalers by affirming a District Court’s dismissal of the Dormant Commerce Clause challenge.  See Orion Imports LLC v. Appelsmith, 2021 WL 733286.

There is at least a circuit split regarding whether the Dormant Commerce Clause prohibits such regulations, and the Supreme Court has written in the past that such conduct at least arguably violates the Dormant Commerce Clause.  See Granholm v. Heald, 544 U.S. 460, 487 (2005).  It is important to note that the precedents all concern wine. Why is it that wineries can ship between states (at least sometimes) but breweries cannot? Stay tuned for a forthcoming law review article this summer that explores this topic in-depth and argues that such laws do in fact violate the Dormant Commerce Clause.

The law school at the William and Mary College is the very definition of “Old School” — it has been around for quite some time (indeed, it is the oldest law school in the nation, sorry, Ivies). The Quick Take, a new law blog produced by the students and faculty at the Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Project at the Law School, has, by contrast, a much newer pedigree. But we don’t think that holds us back, and we’re okay being the new kid on the block, because we’re publishing The Quick Take to support the mission of the Law School’s Property Rights Project (now in its 15th year) to “promote the exchange of ideas between scholars and members of the property rights bar through lectures, an annual conference, and publications.”

The Quick Take a means to disseminate information about the Project’s work, to keep current on new and important developments in property rights law, and to add to our understanding of the law. Topics we’ll cover include the annual Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Prize and Conference, takings and eminent domain (hence our title), cases, legislation, and even careers in Dirt Law (something that law students should always be thinking about).

The blog is produced and published by students and alumni of the Law School – with faculty supervision and guidance – and will also function as a learning platform. No better way to learn about the law than to follow new developments and write about them.

So stay with us, follow along, and join in.

 

I remember two things from working as an intern at OSHA: accidents happen all the time and safety is usually an afterthought. The leading cause of death for people aged 1-44 is unintentional injury; accidents. For people aged 10-34, suicide is number two.

So when I read “Reducing the Stigma: The Deadly Effects of Untreated Mental Illness and New Strategies for Changing Outcomes in Law Students,” the statistics seemed relevant. Well, sort of anyway. I kept obsessing over one line of the law review article:

CNN reported that suicide by occupation (as calculated by the CDC) lists lawyers in the top five.

What CNN actually reported was that “[l]awyers ranked fourth when the proportion of suicides in that profession is compared to suicides in all other occupations in the study population (adjusted for age)” (emphasis added). But CNN does not reference the report from the CDC. The only regular CDC publication regarding suicide and occupation is the Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR). Also, yikes.

Before looking at the data, it is important to note that these statistics are based on civilian, noninstitutionalized, working persons aged 16-64. This means we already have gaps (military, institutionalized, unemployed, and possibly incarcerated).

When compared by sex, male-bodied people are committing suicide at over 3x the rate of female-bodies people. The table below shows the the rates by sex for selected occupations with highest rates (suicides per every 100,000 people).

Occupation Male Occupation Female
 Legal 16.3  Legal 7.9
 Average 27.4  Average 7.7
 Fishing & Hunting Workers 119.9  Artists & Related Workers 45.5
 Artists & Related Workers 93.5  Laborers & Freight, Stock, & Material Movers (Hand) 20.9
 Structural Iron & Steel Workers 79.0  Personal Care Aides 12.1
 Automotive Service Technicians & Mechanics 64.8  Retail Salespersons 11.5
 Chefs & Head Cooks 47.8  Wait Staff 11.3
 Farmers, Ranchers, & Agricultural Managers 43.2  Registered Nurses 10.1

Maybe something changed between 2014 and the current CDC data. Maybe I’m looking at different data. What I’ve found makes me think in a different direction: what impact does the law have on the suicide rates of other occupations?

For example, let’s pretend we are part of a deep sea fishing crew chasing crabs in the Pacific.

Statistically, deep sea fishing crew members are committing suicide at 4x the male average (or 12x the female average). What safeguards have been put into place? Is there annual screening? Victim compensation funds? 10-year plans for industry reform? I know everyone wants to buy king crab at Costco, but don’t we have an obligation to look out for these vulnerable people?

A gross oversimplification of the English common law system is that the law aims to punish evil and protect property. More often than not this gets shunted into the categories of criminal and civil law. In the age of monarchy and feudal obligations, the legal profession was relegated to an even smaller minority of literate people. Often times this minority was composed of clerics from which we get the word “clerk.1” The legal system was extremely formalized and even minor derivations from the prescribed form may result in a case being tossed out. The power of the law was limited in the types of remedies it could provide. To achieve greater fairness or equity, at least since King Edward IV the Crown established the court of Chancery to adjudicate a variety of property cases2.

In England, the Chancellor was a special judge appointed by the Crown to oversee these cases. The Lord chancellor still exists in England to this day. The Chancery courts were different from the “courts of law” in evidentiary requirements, procedure, and most notably the relief they could provide. The Chancery focused almost exclusively on issues of property and contract, thus the remedies are focused on those issues. Equitable remedies included injunctions, specific performance, rescission of contracts, and restitution. For example, if you entered into a contract for the sale of land and a person refused to honor that contract the Chancellor could force the sale. Another example is if a neighbor is repeatedly violating your property by stealing your fruit the court of Chancery could issue an injunction on the neighbor. If the neighbor violated that injunction they could be subject to punishments for contempt of court.

In the United States, the courts of Chancery became fused together with courts of law. Thus, if an individual is seeking both monetary damages, which is a function of law, and an injunction, which is a function of equity, they can achieve both in a single court. A notable exception is that the US still has bankruptcy courts which were traditionally an issue of equity. An even more notable exception is Delaware which still has courts of Chancery. This is part of why so many businesses are incorporated there.

In the late 19th Century with the rise of capitalism, an investor seeking to profit off a venture would purchase a portion of a company. These cumulative shares comprise an individual’s equity in the company. Equity in this instance means the ownership of the company. In bankruptcy, the remaining assets are distributed to those who have equity.

As you can probably imagine this is a very very simplified version of the history of equity. However, I think the key points to remember are that (1) Courts of law and equity were separate. (2) Courts of equity called the Chancery focused on providing a set of remedies relating to property and contracts. (3) Issues of equity functionally different from law even if today they may be adjudicated in a court of law.

Next time we will look at definitions of equity as it is presently used and distinguishing it from its historical and etymological roots.


1. Oxford, The Oxford Dictionary of English Etymology 181 (C.T. Onions, 1966)
Back to text.

2. Thomas A. Robers, Esq., The Principles of the High Court of Chancery, and The Powers and Duties of Its Judges; Designed as The Student’s First Book on Equity Jurisprudence 5 (Wildly and Sons, 1852).
For the remainder of this post, you can assume I am getting my information from this book. If you wish to read it yourself there is a free copy available here.
Back to text.

For reasons I will never quite understand, breweries are often treated differently than wineries in California’s alcohol statutes and regulations (ok, I do understand, it is the powerful wine lobby).  When I tell friends and colleagues that beer law has lots of constitutional nooks and crannies, I often wonder if they believe me.  Here’s some proof.

Today, the California Craft Brewers Association (the “CCBA”) and several independent breweries sued Governor Newsom and California State Public Health (“CDPH”) Officer Sandra Shewry in federal court (Central District of California # 8:20-cv-02372) for violations of the Equal Protection and Due Process Clauses of the United States Constitution for how breweries have been treated during the pandemic and will be treated when things start clearing up.  The Complaint seeks a declaration that the Governor’s executive orders and CDPH Guidance violates both clauses, for an injunction prohibiting California to require breweries to serve sit-down, dine-in meals in order to serve their beer in their tasting rooms (unlike wine), and for attorneys’ fees.  I think the lawsuit has merit.  Of course, the Complaint recognizes the importance of promoting California citizens’ health and safety, but doing so while favoring one class of alcohol manufacturer (wine) over another (beer) is arbitrary.

In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, Governor Newsom issued a series of orders, including a prohibition on beer manufacturers from operating tasting rooms unless they provide meals with any beer served at the tasting room—even if the tasting room never previously sold meals.  Wine tasting rooms, on the other hand, do not have to serve food with wine at their tasting rooms.  Oddly, the Complaint notes that even wineries that share tasting rooms with breweries can sell and serve wine without food, but the beer manufacturer must still serve food.  The Complaint further points out that the state has provided no scientific evidence or explanation for this differing treatment.  The bottom line is that the CCBA and the brewery plaintiffs allege that winery tasting rooms and brewery tasting rooms are similarly situated, if not identically situated, and therefore there is no basis to treat them so differently.  I agree, especially with many breweries facing closure and an inability to move product at all.  This is a discrimination case.

Here is what seems to be the crux of the problem.  On May 12, 2020, the CDPH issued an order stating, “Brewpubs, breweries, bars, pubs, craft distilleries and wineries should remain closed until those establishments are allowed to resume modified or full operation unless they are offering sit-down, dine-in meals.  Alcohol can only be sold in the same transaction as a meal.”  Ok, so far.  Everyone is being treated equally.

Then, on June 28 and July 1, 2020, the CDHP eliminated the need for wine manufacturers to serve meals with their wine. Specifically, the July 1 closure Guidance ordered “all brewpubs, breweries, bars, and pubs in these counties must close, both indoors and outdoors, unless they are offering sit down, din-in meals….”  What happened to wine tasting rooms?  They got a pass.  The CDPH offered no explanation as to why wineries can sell wine only, but breweries must serve sit-down, dine-in meals to sell a pint.  Later, the CDPH attempted to justify the differing treatment in a letter to the CCBA by alleging, essentially, that brewery tasting rooms are in urban areas and wineries are not and that wineries are generally not social hubs for people to meet.  That’s just not true.

Regarding the Equal Protection Clause, the complaint proceeds as follows:  (1) the Fourteenth Amendment forbids any state to “deny to any person within its jurisdiction equal protection of laws”; (2) beer and wine manufacturers are similarly situated; (3) Governor Newsom and the CDPH have treated beer manufacturers differently than wine manufacturers regarding the sit-down meal requirement; (4) there is no rational basis for the differing treatment; and, therefore, (5) the order and guidance are unconstitutional.  In a nice stroke of the pen, the Complaint alleges that “imposing the sit-down, dine-in meal requirement on beer manufacturers does not keep California citizens who seek an alcoholic beverage at home entirely, it just sends them to the winery instead—which is likely to be very nearby (or even next door) to the beer manufacturer they would have visited.”

The Due Process cause of action proceeds similarly and focuses on breweries’ deprivation of conducting their lawful business and the detrimental impact on their liberty and property interests.  Further, the Complaint alleges the CDPH guidance is arbitrary and invites arbitrary enforcement.  Perhaps most importantly, at least for procedural due process, the Complaint focuses on the fact that the CDPH guidance was implemented without a constitutionally-adequate hearing and provides no meaningful procedure to challenge the restrictions.

Why do I think this has merit?  The Complaint alleges the disparate treatment of similarly situated “persons” and provides extensive allegations about the state’s lack of any evidence, scientific or otherwise, that could rationally justify the orders.  And if the state tries to argue that its Twenty-first Amendment powers give it broad power to regulate alcohol as it sees fit, it should read 44 Liquormart, Inc. v. Rhode Island, 517 U.S. 484, 516 (1996) where the Supreme Court recognized that the Twenty-first Amendment “does not license the States to ignore their obligations under other provisions of the Constitution.”  To be more specific, the Court relied on “our specific holdings that the Twenty-first Amendment does not in any way diminish the force of the Supremacy Clause, the Establishment Clause, or the Equal Protection Clause.”  Id. (citations omitted; emphasis added).  Thus, the Twenty-first Amendment will not save unconstitutional infringement on breweries’ rights.

Good luck to the CCBA and the named independent brewers.  We’re rooting for you.  Did I mention that Governor Newsom is a winery owner?

 

 

 

The Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (known as the TTB) is the federal agency charged with enforcing the Federal Alcohol Administration Act and enacting regulations governing the alcoholic beverage industry.  This includes everything from the federal tied-house restrictions (27 U.S.C. § 205(b)) to the propriety of the labels you see on your craft beers.  Oh, it also collects the taxes.  The TTB has authority over beer shipped interstate.

Under the federal tied-house law, it is illegal for a brewery to directly or indirectly induce a retailer engaged in the sale of alcoholic beverages to purchase beer from the brewery to the exclusion, in whole or in part, of other breweries.  Stated less technically, a beer manufacturer can’t induce a retailer to favor its beer over others.  See 27 U.S.C. § 205(b).  Inducements include such items as “furnishing, giving, renting, lending, or selling to the retailer any equipment, fixtures, signs, supplies, money, services or other thing of value” and by “extending to the retailer credit for a period in excess of the credit period usual and customary to the industry for the particular class of transactions.”  27 U.S.C. § 205(b)(3); see 27 CFR 6.21(c).  In other words, a manufacturer can’t pay to play.  Commercial bribery is illegal (I see you industry folks smirking).

A common violation that many are not aware of is that the sale of alcohol with the privilege of return is prohibited with some exceptions.  In other words, a brewery (or wholesaler) cannot sell its beer to a retailer and then accept a return if the beer fails to move off the shelves (known charmingly in the industry as a “shelf turd”).

The TTB is attempting to extend a helping hand to retailers (and thus breweries by extension) during the COVID crisis by relaxing some of these restrictions.  Specifically, as mentioned above, extensions of credit to retailers beyond 30 days is considered an inducement.  However, the TTB’s latest industry circular (available here:  https://www.ttb.gov/industry-circulars/ttb-industry-circular-2020-3) states that it will not enforce this restriction for extensions of credit for up to 120 days.  But this does not allow a brewery to extend credit to a retailer until the product is sold—that would still be an inducement.  Returns are now allowable if the beer was purchased for an event that was cancelled due to COIVD-19.

In addition, to help retailers in need, the TTB is allowing manufacturers to purchase prepaid gift cards to consumers as long as they are not “tied to an alcoholic beverage retailer, retailer group, or restaurant.”  It is up to the consumer to determine where to spend the gift card, but the manufacturer can encourage consumers to spend them to support retailers or restaurants of the consumer’s choice.  The gift card has to be a generic one, like a Visa gift card, and cannot be a gift card to a particular retailer.  Further, the TTB has stated that it will not investigate donations to charities that support retailers and their employees.  And of course, manufacturers can provide consumers with hand sanitizer.  These would all be considered inducements pre-COVID.

Sigh.  Thanks for the effort.  While these things might provide some relief to a limited number of retailers, there is so much more the government could be doing to help craft breweries.  How about passing the Craft Beverage Modernization and Tax Reform Act that is about to expire?  See prior post.  How about not shutting down outdoor dining when there is no evidence that it contributes to the spread of COVID-19 (state and local issue, I know)?  The bottom line is that big crises require big ideas.  Extensions of credit and hand sanitzer are but a blip on the screen.  Let’s think bigger, government, unless we don’t want craft breweries and the vibrant culture they bring to communities.  This is not hyperbole.